Former Intelligence Chief Sues Netanyahu, Exposing Israeli Prime Minister’s Failings
Former Israeli intelligence chief Ronen Bar has formally sued Benjamin Netanyahu for defamation. He accuses the prime minister of deliberately ignoring multiple intelligence warnings ahead of Hamas’s 7 October 2023 attack and trying to shift blame for the failure of the country’s security system.
According to Russia Today on Thursday (15 October 2026), Bar, who headed Israel’s domestic security agency, Shin Bet, during the deadly attack, filed a lawsuit worth 3 million shekels, or nearly US$1 million (Rp17.9 billion), on Wednesday. Netanyahu had previously accused Bar of deliberately withholding intelligence and failing to put military forces on alert or evacuate attendees at the Nova music festival.
Bar flatly rejects the allegations, arguing that Netanyahu is trying to evade responsibility for an attack that killed about 1,200 people and saw 251 taken hostage. According to Gaza’s Health Ministry, Israel’s retaliatory military campaign in the territory has killed more than 74,300 Palestinians.
The lawsuit documents say Shin Bet officers began sharing intelligence about unusual Hamas activity with the military on the evening of 6 October. Bar then issued a formal warning at 3.03am.
Netanyahu’s military secretariat was also updated at 3.55am, while Bar’s chief of staff briefed the prime minister’s military secretary shortly after 6am. Bar firmly denies speaking directly with Israel’s military chief or military intelligence chief that night, contradicting Netanyahu’s account.
Bar has acknowledged that Shin Bet failed to anticipate the scale and timing of the attack and did not provide an adequate warning. He accepted responsibility for the failure, which contributed to his decision to resign.
However, he insists Netanyahu was repeatedly warned of the risk. Bar cites a letter from February 2023 warning that internal divisions in Israel and instability in the Palestinian territories could embolden its adversaries to attack.
In July, Bar also claims to have personally raised the prospect of an attack, warning that intelligence agencies might not be able to predict it precisely.
The lawsuit details further warnings in September and early October about Hamas’s growing capabilities. Bar accuses Netanyahu of repeatedly rejecting or delaying proposals to target senior Hamas figures because he prioritised keeping the situation in Gaza calm at any cost.
The prime minister is also alleged in the documents to have continued allowing Qatari money into the territory despite strong warnings that the humanitarian funds were flowing directly to Hamas’s military wing. Netanyahu has dismissed the claims, arguing that the former intelligence chief should have taken the initiative himself.
“Bar could have contacted me through the secure emergency channel,” Netanyahu said.
“I have submitted nearly 1,000 documents to rebut all of Bar’s testimony,” he said, adding that he had substantial evidence to contest the lawsuit comprehensively.
In March 2025, the government controversially voted to dismiss Bar, citing a loss of confidence. At the time, Shin Bet was investigating allegations that Netanyahu’s aides had promoted Qatar’s interests, claims that the prime minister’s office strongly denied.
Israel’s Supreme Court later ruled the dismissal unlawful. Bar eventually resigned voluntarily in June.
The lawsuit follows reports that Netanyahu had also received early warnings from foreign governments. Haaretz reported in September that the President of the United Arab Emirates, Mohamed bin Zayed, had warned him of the possibility of a major Hamas operation ten days before the attack. Netanyahu’s office immediately dismissed the allegation as an outright lie.
The Atlantic and The Wall Street Journal have separately reported similar warnings from Egyptian officials. The New York Times revealed that Israeli intelligence had obtained Hamas’s battle plan, known as “Jericho Wall”, more than a year earlier.
Despite the reports, Netanyahu continues to deny receiving warnings from Egypt or being shown the secret Hamas plan.
The political fallout from the scandals is expected to intensify ahead of Israel’s parliamentary election on 27 October. Amid mounting criticism, Netanyahu continues to accuse his opponents of exploiting the 7 October tragedy purely for political gain.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/former-intelligence-chief-sues-netanyahu-exposing-israeli-prime-ministers-failings-1792075884)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261015122517-4-776444/mantan-bos-intelijen-gugat-netanyahu-ungkap-borok-pm-israel), translated from Indonesian