Forgotten Baby Syndrome: How a Momentary Lapse Can Turn a Car into a Death Trap
Bryce was only nine months old when he died from heatstroke inside a car. His mother, Lyn Balfour, had not taken him to childcare that day, but instead brought him to work and forgot him in the vehicle. This incident occurred in 2007 in the United States.
Since then, hundreds of infants and toddlers have been recorded dying in similar circumstances, including a recent case in Germany.
A car can transform into a death trap in a very short time. At an outside temperature of 30 degrees Celsius and under direct sunlight, the temperature inside a car can reach 40 degrees within just ten minutes, and after one hour, it can exceed 50 degrees Celsius.
“This is dangerous for anyone,” said Nibras Naami, a specialist in paediatrics and adolescent medicine and a senior doctor at the Centre for Paediatric Haematology in Herdecke, Germany. “A toddler strapped into a child seat cannot free themselves from such a situation,” he explained.
In mid-June, a 20-month-old child left in a car was found dead due to heat. In an Instagram post, Na0adNaami explained the likely cause as “Forgotten Baby Syndrome”, which refers to unintentional negligence—leaving a child in a car. This can happen to parents who are cognitively functioning, attentive, and deeply loving towards their children.
What is Forgotten Baby Syndrome?
Of course, there are also cases where parents neglect their children and therefore leave them in a car for too long, the paediatrician noted. However, doctors and psychologists believe that this explanation is insufficient for many cases.
David Diamond is a psychologist who has spent years researching how this occurs: parents simply forget their children.
The case of Bryce from the US mentioned above was explained by Diamond in a scientific article. His mother, Lyn Balfour, was charged with manslaughter. During the trial, it was revealed that on the day of Bryce’s death, several things were different from usual.
Balfour was sleep-deprived and had to deal with a family crisis. Her routine also appeared different. The diaper bag, which usually serves as a visual reminder of the baby’s presence in the car, was not placed in an easily visible spot, such as the passenger seat.
All these factors, wrote David Diamond, affect prospective memory, also known as intention memory. This is the memory of actions to be performed in the future, such as taking medication before bed, returning a call to a colleague after lunch, or stopping at a supermarket on the way home.
Diamond explained six factors that disrupt prospective memory and can cause us to forget planned actions: lack of sleep, chronic or acute stress, distraction, multitasking, lack of memory aids, and automatic routines.
These factors cause internal tension, said Rya-Daniela Kocalevent, a psychologist in Berlin. If tension is too high, acting rationally becomes very difficult. “We then act impulsively or rely on ‘autopilot’,” said Kocalevent. As a result, planned actions are forgotten, such as taking medication on time, attending appointments, or even a baby sitting in a car.
Intentional or Negligent: When was Forgotten Baby Syndrome first detected?
“We can never be 100% certain what is on someone’s mind,” said Kocalevent. To assess whether parents have intentionally endangered their child’s life by leaving them in an overheated car, psychologists observe previous behaviour, learning history, and the parents’ background. “Past behaviour is one way to predict future behaviour.”
Thus, this becomes the most appropriate way to conclude whether a deviation in routine or external stress factors triggered the fatal error. Whether such behaviour can be prosecuted remains a matter for the courts.
In the trial, it could not be proven that Lyn Balfour intended to harm her son. Her brain had stored a memory that she believed to be true, even though it never happened: that Bryce, as happened every day, was in a safe childcare facility. A real but erroneous memory. This phenomenon has been a focus of cognitive psychology for decades.
Child seats with anti-negligence alarm systems
After Nibras Naami posted his video about “Forgotten Baby Syndrome”, he received many messages. Parents shared that similar things had happened to them. “One mother wrote that she once left her two-week-old baby in the car after dropping an older child at kindergarten and returning home,” said Naami. She realised her mistake immediately, and at that time, the weather was not hot, so the baby was fine.
Italy does not want to rely on luck. Since 2019, the country has only permitted baby seats with integrated alarm signals to be used for children up to four years old. If a child is forgotten in a car, parents will receive a message on their mobile phones.
In Germany, there are not yet similar regulations, but there are many options for alarm systems that parents can install on child seats in their cars.
Placing a mobile phone or briefcase in the back seat, or using a baby toy in the front passenger seat as a visual reminder, are other ways to prevent “Forgotten Baby Syndrome”. However, none of these methods provide one hundred per cent protection.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/forgotten-baby-syndrome-how-a-momentary-lapse-can-turn-a-car-into-a-death-trap-1782806003)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8553649/sindrom-bayi-yang-terlupakan-sebabkan-anak-tewas-kepanasan-dalam-mobil), translated from Indonesian