Foreword Author of 'Memburu Muhammad' Urges Full Reading of the Book
Nadirsyah Hosen has requested that the controversy surrounding the book ‘Memburu Muhammad’ by Feby Indirani be approached with composure and a complete reading of the work. Nadirsyah is the author of the foreword for the book, which was originally published in 2020.
In a post on his personal Instagram account, @nadirsyahhosen_official, Nadirsyah explained that while the title ‘Memburu Muhammad’ (Hunting Muhammad) may have shocked some individuals, such shock does not serve as evidence of an insult to Islam or the Prophet Muhammad SAW.
He clarified that within the story, the character Abu Jahal is depicted hunting individuals named Muhammad in the modern world. Therefore, according to Nadirsyah, the actions of a fictional character should not be immediately used to level accusations against the author.
“The one doing the hunting is Abu Jahal, a character in the story. Conflating the actions of a character with accusations against the author is a fundamental reading error,” Nadirsyah wrote.
Nadirsyah also stated that he found no insults to Islam or the Prophet Muhammad in either the title or the plot. Instead, he perceives a critique regarding the gap between the noble character of the Prophet Muhammad and the behaviour of those who claim to love him. “What I found is rather a challenge to the distance between the nobility of the Prophet’s character and our own behaviour as those who claim to love him,” he wrote.
According to Nadirsyah, allegations of blasphemy must be accompanied by clear evidence and context. He noted that readers need to examine the disputed sections in their entirety, including whether the statements are the words of a character, the actions of a character, or the overall message of the story. “The repetition of accusations cannot replace proof,” he remarked.
The controversy surrounding ‘Memburu Muhammad’ gained momentum after a discussion regarding the book, part of the Bogor Literature Week, was cancelled on 20 September 2026. The polemic has since escalated, with the Polda Metro Jaya (Metropolitan Regional Police) stating they will investigate allegations of religious blasphemy related to the book.
Nadirsyah has invited both objecting parties and readers to open a space for dialogue. He also requested that the work be read collectively, allowing critics to express their grievances and the author to explain the intent of her writing. “Not all differences must be resolved immediately. What matters is that everyone can leave without feeling threatened or belittled,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/foreword-author-of-memburu-muhammad-urges-full-reading-of-the-book-1790614532)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tm31bw483/jadi-penulis-kata-pengantar-memburu-muhammad-nadirsyah-hosen-minta-buku-itu-dibaca-utuh), translated from Indonesian