Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Foreigner in Bali Removes All Indonesians from WhatsApp Group, Sparking Outrage

| Source: detikBali Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Foreigner in Bali Removes All Indonesians from WhatsApp Group, Sparking Outrage
Image: detikBali

Italian content creator Christian Giacobbe has exposed alleged discriminatory behaviour by a foreign national named Sergey Melnikov, who is said to have removed all Indonesian citizens from the WhatsApp group ‘Garage Sales in Amed’.

In a video uploaded to his account @chrisgiacobbecomedy, Chris said Sergey had at one point removed every Indonesian member from the group.

‘This is Sergey, the creator of the Garage Sales in Amed group. At one point, he decided to remove all Indonesians from the group,’ he said in the video posted on his account on Monday (27/7/2026).

According to Chris, Sergey justified the removal on the grounds that the Indonesian members were deemed to have broken the group’s rules. In a screenshot shown in the video, Sergey wrote that the group was indeed intended for the expatriate community. However, as more and more local residents joined and began to disregard the rules, he decided to remove them so that foreign members would feel safer.

‘This group was supposed to be intended for the expatriate community. However, because more and more locals have joined and started ignoring the rules, I decided to remove them so that all foreigners feel safer. I can readmit those who promise to follow the rules. Please don’t take this personally,’ Sergey wrote.

Chris, however, considered the reasoning illogical and discriminatory. A number of group members also protested the decision, saying those removed had never broken any rules.

Among the comments shown in the video were:

‘What? You just removed all Indonesians from the group? Good grief.’

‘I hope not. I think this group is really useful. It would be sad if all locals were removed just for using the +62 country code.’

‘Wow, you just removed my partner, even though she never broke any of the rules you made.’

After drawing numerous protests, Sergey subsequently issued a clarification. He said the group was initially created as a venue for the expatriate community in Amed to buy and sell second-hand goods, not to become a large community group.

Sergey also said he had recently received many messages from members questioning the safety of activities within the group. According to him, these concerns arose amid widespread news coverage of immigration crackdowns said to have been triggered by reports from local residents.

‘Recently I have received many messages questioning the safety of activities in the group because of extensive news coverage of immigration enforcement following reports from local residents. Although selling second-hand goods is not a problem, there have been posts about subletting, selling goods from outside Indonesia, and offering various services,’ Sergey wrote.

Meanwhile, Husnan, spokesperson for the Ngurah Rai Class I Special Immigration Office, said the authorities would first verify the information.

‘We will check first. From our side, we focus on each of their residence permits,’ he said.

Husnan explained that activity within the WhatsApp group falls within the private sphere. Nevertheless, Immigration will investigate whether any activities violate legal provisions should reports be filed.

‘If a report comes in, it will be followed up immediately,’ he concluded.

More from 28 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/foreigner-in-bali-removes-all-indonesians-from-whatsapp-group-sparking-outrage-1785250321)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/berita/d-8594501/viral-wna-di-bali-keluarkan-semua-wni-dari-grup-wa-alasannya-tuai-kecaman), translated from Indonesian
Print