Foreign Investors in Bali Allegedly Manipulate Permits, Converting Real Estate Projects into Villas
The Bali Provincial Government is highlighting allegations of permit manipulation by foreign investors (PMA). Companies registered with permits for real estate development are reportedly converting completed buildings into villas to be rented out on a daily basis.
This pattern has drawn the attention of the Bali Provincial Government because the actual business activities on the ground are deemed inconsistent with the business classifications stated in their licences. The Head of the Bali Provincial Investment and One-Stop Integrated Services Agency (DPMPUSPT), I Ketut Sukra Negara, stated that this issue represents a significant challenge in supervising foreign investment in Bali.
According to Sukra Negara, foreign-invested companies entering Bali generally must specify their business activities in their permits. One frequently used classification is KBLI 6811, relating to real estate development. However, problems arise when field operations no longer align with the permitted classification.
“Usually, when PMAs come to Bali, alongside the trend of virtual offices, the most common use is KBLI 6811 for real estate development,” said Sukra Negara on Thursday (1/10/2026). He further explained the pattern concerning the provincial government: “The fact is, once the real estate is completed, they convert it into villas. The permit is 6811 for real estate, but in practice, they use it for accommodation such as villas, renting them out daily.”
Sukra Negara noted that this situation is problematic because villa businesses have different characteristics and regulations compared to real estate development. He emphasised that villa businesses in Bali are intended to serve as spaces for MSMEs (Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises). Therefore, the entry of foreign investors through other business classifications to operate villas requires strict supervision.
“Foreign investors in Bali are actually prohibited from using the villa KBLI classification. This is because we prioritise the villa sector for our MSMEs,” Sukra Negara added.
Licensing Inconsistent with Field Practices
Sukra Negara stated that the challenge of foreign investment in Bali involves more than just the volume of capital entering the province. The government also faces the challenge of ensuring that investor activities comply with the issued permits. He noted that the misuse of business classifications is a common issue found during inspections.
This condition allows a company to appear as though it is conducting a specific business activity within the licensing system, while the actual operations on the ground are different. In the cases highlighted by the Bali Provincial Government, companies are recorded as performing real estate development, but once construction is complete, the buildings are utilised as villas for tourists.
While Sukra Negara did not name specific companies or the total number of companies using this pattern, the provincial government intends to conduct further investigations to ensure the alignment of Business Identification Numbers (NIB), KBLI, building permits, and actual business activities.
Bali Investment Reaches Rp 23.77 Trillion, Majority from Foreign Capital
Scrutiny of these foreign investment practices comes amidst a massive influx of investment into Bali. Sukra Negara reported that Bali’s investment realisation up to the second quarter of 2026 reached approximately Rp 23.77 trillion, against a 2026 target of Rp 47.93 trillion. This investment is dominated by foreign capital (PMA), which accounts for about Rp 14.9 trillion.
However, Bali’s investment structure remains heavily concentrated in the tertiary sector. The hotel and restaurant sector is the largest contributor, valued at around Rp 9 trillion as of Q2 2026, followed by housing, industrial estates, and offices at approximately Rp 7 trillion. Other services account for Rp 4 trillion, trade and repairs for Rp 1 trillion, and transport, warehousing, and telecommunications for around Rp 874 billion.
“The hotel and restaurant sectors have held the highest records in Bali for the last five years because most investment destinations in Bali are tertiary-sector hotels and restaurants,” said Sukra Negara. He noted that this dominance is reflected in the 2025 structure, where the primary sector (agriculture, livestock, and fisheries) accounted for only 0.9%, the secondary sector for 2%, and the tertiary sector for 97.4%.
Bali Government Highlights Investment Pressures
Sukra Negara warned that the surge in investment must be viewed alongside Bali’s carrying capacity. Investment growth brings economic activity but also potential pressure on space and the environment if left uncontrolled. He cited several challenges, including the conversion of rice fields, increased waste volume, ecosystem damage, threats to energy availability, traffic congestion, and limited public infrastructure and transport.
Furthermore, the Bali Provincial Government is concerned about the diminishing opportunities for local communities. Sukra Negara mentioned the practice of foreign nationals using Indonesian citizens’ names for business ownership, known as the ‘nominee system,’ as a major concern.
“The systemic nominee practice, where Indonesian citizens are used as shareholders for non-Indonesian investors, is a concern,” he said. He noted that this pattern can make businesses actually controlled by foreign parties appear to be owned by Indonesian citizens.
The suspected conversion of real estate into villas is part of a broader issue in supervising investment in Bali. The government is tasked not only with meeting investment targets but also ensuring that incoming capital operates within regulations and does not encroach upon business spaces reserved for local players, especially as Bali pursues its 2026 target of Rp 47.93 trillion.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/foreign-investors-in-bali-allegedly-manipulate-permits-converting-real-estate-projects-into-villas-1790841095)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8687648/pma-di-bali-diduga-akali-izin-bangunan-real-estat-disulap-jadi-vila), translated from Indonesian