Food for thought
Food for thought
The government must be commended for launching the crash
program this month to provide rice at a heavily subsidized price
to millions of poor people who are most vulnerable to food
shortages. The economic crisis, coming immediately after the
prolonged drought last year, has increased the number of people
in poverty to about 80 million. Of these, more than 40 million
people, or 7.35 million families, are in dire need of a helping
hand, or else they face starvation.
A famine of this scale in Indonesia is simply beyond anybody's
imagination. The threat is real and should not be underestimated
due to the number of people it has impoverished. Millions of
urban and rural people have been left without work, and those
fortunate to have jobs have seen their earnings and savings
rapidly depleted by soaring inflation.
We recall how often the government of former president
Soeharto repeatedly gloated, even as late as last year, of its
success in bringing down the number of people living in poverty
from 60 percent when he took over in 1966, to 11 percent by the
start of 1997. The economic crisis, for which Soeharto was
primarily responsible, has virtually wiped out all those gains.
The latest government survey shows that 40 percent of the
population is now living in poverty, and at the rate the economy
is deteriorating, the number could increase further.
President B.J. Habibie has determined the provision of basic
foodstuffs as the chief priority of his government, even more
important than the long-awaited political reforms. Habibie has
established a food crisis center and has canceled virtually all
public investments and is using the government's limited budget
for the provision of basic foodstuffs. He has also secured the
agreement of the International Monetary Fund to continue
providing subsidies for food and medicine.
Under the program announced Wednesday, the government will
sell medium-quality rice at Rp 1,000 a kilogram to poor people.
This is about one-third of the going rate. Each family is
entitled to 10 kg a month. While this may be only about a third
or a quarter of the rice consumed by a typical family, any help,
no matter how small, to ease their plight should be welcome.
A word of caution is needed however. This crash program must
not be turned into a publicity stunt to bolster the popularity of
the government of Habibie, the way the previous government did
with its free meal program. The then social services minister,
Siti Hardijanti Rukmana, who is also Soeharto's eldest daughter,
used the program as part of her PR exercise, touring the nation,
giving away meals and eating with the poor, in the constant glare
of TV cameras. The program served no one but herself, for the
poor only received one free meal before Hardijanti moved on to
the next town for her next stunt.
Since doubts still linger about the legitimacy of the May
transfer of power from Soeharto to Habibie, it is tempting for
the new President to turn to populist measures in order to win
widespread support. But he would be well advised against
exploiting the prospect of massive famine for his political end.
The rice program can only be a temporary relief. The
government said the program will run for nine months, and will
require 750,000 tons of rice at a total cost of Rp 503 billion.
This is certainly not sustainable. In the medium and long run,
relief must come in different, and indirect ways.
The government must bring inflation under control, and this
includes strengthening the rupiah's exchange rate. The government
must restore the food distribution network which was severely
damaged by the riots when shops and supermarkets, mostly owned by
Chinese-Indonesians, were looted and burned. The poor
distribution network, or lack of it, contributed to the soaring
rice prices, particularly in the regions.
Ultimately, the poor people need their jobs back, so the
government must work harder to get the economic wheels going
again. No one likes to accept charity and this program of selling
rice at a subsidized price is a charity act. If the government
really intends to help the poor, then let the people help
themselves out of their poverty. As the popular Indonesian saying
goes, give the poor the fishing rod, not the fish.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/food-for-thought-1447893297-1407822)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post