Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Floating state firms

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Floating state firms

The successful initial public offerings of the four state
companies over the past two years seems to have convinced the
Indonesian government that public listing is the best method for
its privatization program. Director General of State Enterprises
Bacelius Ruru even considered public share offering as the jewel
of future privatization.

Ruru told a capital market conference last week that
privatization through share floatations would enable the
government to simultaneously achieve several goals: raising fresh
funds for foreign debt repayments and new investments, enhancing
a more equitable ownership of economic assets, increasing the
efficiency of state firms and strengthening the domestic stock
markets.

The policy statement should be good music to the ears of
businessmen and the investing public. It may signal a significant
improvement in the way the government privatizes state companies
in the future. Our reservation, though, is that Ruru is not the
one who makes the final decision, even though he acts on behalf
of the finance minister as the government's nominee owner of all
state companies. In addition, the government has often acted
quite differently from what it likes to proclaim.

It is true that privatization through share floatations offers
more advantages than private placement. Public share offering
makes the privatization process widely transparent, because the
pricing of the assets is based on the market mechanism. Public
listing also enhances the accountability of companies because
they are subject to more stringent disclosure requirements and
audits.

Of great importance, also -- especially with regard to
Indonesian state companies -- is that a publicly-listed company
is protected from excessive government intervention. Even though
the government retains majority ownership of a listed state
company, the capital market rulings serve to minimize government
meddling in the company's operations and management.

Excessive government intervention has been identified as one
of the biggest problems encountered by state companies and their
managements often are not empowered with managerial autonomy.
That is a major disadvantage -- especially now -- when most of
the sectors previously monopolized by state firms have been
opened to free market competition, and rapid changes are the name
of the game in the marketplace.

There are at least two ministers that the management of a
state company has to deal with: the minister of finance, as the
government's nominee shareholder (owner), and the ministry which
oversees the areas in which the company operates. In reality,
however, a state company is vulnerable to intervention from many
other high officials. Their status as a public company often
creates the perception that everybody high in the government
bureaucratic hierarchy can meddle with the state firms.

Ruru understandably did not mention another factor that makes
private placement the least-preferred mode of privatization.
Private placement makes the process and transaction highly
vulnerable to political pressures. Past experiences show how the
pricing of a state asset to be sold was done deliberately to the
great benefit of politically well-connected buyers or investors.
Even though the deals were claimed to have been concluded through
competitive tenders, the process was not really transparent to
public scrutiny. The evaluation of the bids was often biased
against certain bidders with powerful political connections.

In fact, we may soon notice another instance of inconsistency
between official pronouncements and actual measures. The case in
point is the plan by the national flag-carrier Garuda to sell its
highly profitable hotel subsidiary, PT Aerowisata, which owns and
manages nine hotels in major tourist destination areas. Garuda
has yet to announce how the hotels will be sold, but such
politically well-connected businessmen as Hutomo Mandala Putra,
with his Humpuss group, and Sudwikatmono were reported to be
among the strongest candidate buyers of the "jewels" among the
nine hotels. If the government is really serious about pursuing
what it sees as the best method of privatization, we wonder why
PT Aerowisata has not been prepared for public listing. After
all, the hotel chain is fully qualified to enter the domestic
stock exchanges.

More from 14 August 1996 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/floating-state-firms-1447893297-1058125)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print