Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Fiqh Muamalah Ethics in COD Transactions: Buyers Cannot Cancel Arbitrarily on the Spot

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Fiqh Muamalah Ethics in COD Transactions: Buyers Cannot Cancel Arbitrarily on the Spot
Image: Republika

Recently, social media feeds have frequently featured videos of couriers being harassed by buyers due to Cash on Delivery (COD) issues. The pattern involves buyers refusing to pay because the item does not meet expectations after the package has already been opened, forcing the courier to turn back with the returned goods. This phenomenon is more than just a technical misunderstanding of online shopping; it is a serious alarm that literacy in Fiqh Muamalah (Islamic jurisprudence of transactions) remains very low in our society. Many mistakenly view COD as a facility to “inspect the goods before paying,” unaware that arbitrary cancellations at the doorstep violate the principles of justice in Islam.

One fundamental aspect often forgotten is the moral consequence of pressing the “Buy with COD” button on an application. From the perspective of Fiqert, that action is not merely a casual click, but a binding promise (wa’ad) that creates legal responsibility. By choosing this option, the buyer indirectly commits to the seller to settle the payment, while simultaneously promising the expedition company to pay for the delivery service upon arrival. Islam is very strict regarding the maintenance of commitments, as stated in Surah Al-Ma’idah verse 1, which commands believers to fulfil their promises. Therefore, unilaterally cancelling an order at the doorstep without a clear emergency is a form of denial of that commitment.

The negative impact of this habit of arbitrary cancellation also directly violates a fundamental principle of Fiqh: one must not cause harm to oneself or others (La dharara wa la dhirara). Trade in Islam must be based on the principles of mutual consent and economic justice. The logic is simple: when a package is rejected on the spot, a chain of financial losses is shifted onto the shoulders of others. Sellers suffer capital losses due to return shipping costs and the risk of goods being damaged in transit. Meanwhile, couriers who have endured the heat on the road lose time, energy, and fuel for a package that ultimately becomes futile. Protecting one’s own wallet by sacrificing the hard work of others is certainly not a blessed way to conduct transactions.

However, what if a buyer is truly a victim of fraud by a dishonest seller? Does the buyer not have the right to cancel the transaction if the goods are defective? In Fiqh Muamalah, this rule is accommodated through the concept of Hak Khiyar (the right to rescind). However, what needs to be clarified is the mechanism of its application in the digital era. Current e-commerce platforms already provide a neat complaint system through official return features. The ethical and Sharia-compliant path is to pay the courier for the package first as a form of fulfilling the delivery service rights. After that, the package may be opened. If the contents are unsatisfactory or incorrect, an official complaint should be lodged with the seller via the application so that the money can be refunded by the system. Resolving the issue by arguing with the courier at the doorstep is not an application of Hak Khiyar, but rather an irresponsible act directed at the wrong party.

Ultimately, the COD system exists as an inclusive solution, especially for those without access to digital banking. The problem lies not with the payment system, but with consumer behaviour that has not yet matured in conducting transactions (muamalah). Fiqh is not always about complex Islamic banking theories; it begins with small things, such as respecting the courier’s profession and being responsible for what we have ordered. Being a smart consumer is not just about finding discounts, but also about knowing how to ensure that every transaction we perform does not leave a trace of injustice for others.

More from 25 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/fiqh-muamalah-ethics-in-cod-transactions-buyers-cannot-cancel-arbitrarily-on-the-spot-1782359546)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/766314/etika-fiqh-muamalah-dalam-transaksi-cod-pembeli-tidak-boleh-asal-cancel-di-tempat), translated from Indonesian
Print