Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Fallout from Constitutional Court Ruling on Vice-President Gibran’s Educational Qualifications

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Fallout from Constitutional Court Ruling on Vice-President Gibran’s Educational Qualifications
Image: detikcom

The Constitutional Court (MK) said in its ruling that it had found no evidence showing that Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka held a high-school-equivalent certificate. A range of comments followed the court’s decision on Gibran’s educational qualifications.

As reported by detikcom on Friday (9 October 2026), the court rejected an election-result dispute concerning the educational requirements Gibran met when registering for the 2024 presidential election. However, it found no evidence that he had a high-school-equivalent certificate. The ruling was delivered at the Constitutional Court building in Jakarta on Tuesday (6 October).

Constitutional Court Justice Arsul Sani explained that a certificate of attendance had been used as the basis for issuing a letter stating that Gibran had completed education equivalent to senior high school abroad. He said there were no documents showing that Gibran had completed high school overseas.

“Meanwhile, the certificate of attendance and other documents used as the basis for issuing Letter No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019 say nothing about successfully completing a particular level of education; they only confirm attendance at classes,” Arsul said.

Nevertheless, the court said it could not disqualify Gibran.

“The court cannot annul or disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka from his position as Vice-President, as requested in the petitioners’ formal plea,” Constitutional Court Justice Adies Kadir said.

PDI-P comments

PDI-P central board chair and House of Representatives Commission II member Komarudin Watubun commented on the court’s finding that it had not seen evidence of Gibran’s high-school-equivalent certificate. He said Gibran should consider resigning as an expression of obedience to the law.

“There are only two things here. Everything was made clear yesterday. If Mr Gibran feels that he has always spoken about obeying the law and being committed to it, the Constitutional Court has laid everything out, so resigning would be better,” Komarudin said at the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Thursday (8 October).

Komarudin said leaders chosen by the public should not lie, even though they may make mistakes. In his view, a leader who has lied should resign.

“I would say that a leader may make mistakes but must not lie,” he said.

“So if he feels that this is part of a lie, resigning would be better,” he added.

PDI-P parliamentary faction chair Utut Adianto said his party would examine the court’s ruling. He said legal decisions needed to be discussed in detail.

“We need to examine the legal language carefully,” Utut said at the parliamentary complex in Senayan on Thursday (8 October 2026).

Utut said the ruling on Gibran’s certificate should be discussed with PDI-P secretary-general Hasto Kristiyanto. He added that the discussion should also involve House Speaker and PDI-P central board chair Puan Maharani.

“This isn’t something that one person, Utut, can assess. We need to speak with the secretary-general and the faction leaders. The House Speaker is currently on duty. That’s how it should be put. The point is that we all understand,” Utut said.

Jokowi responds

Indonesia’s seventh president, Joko Widodo (Jokowi), responded to the Constitutional Court’s finding that it had not seen evidence of Gibran’s high-school-equivalent qualification. Jokowi said education systems differ from country to country, including the system Gibran followed at secondary-school level.

“Every country has a different education system. Here, the stages are primary school, junior high, senior high, and university, or there are also diploma courses. Other countries have their own systems,” Jokowi said at his home in Sumber, Banjarsari, as reported by detikJateng on Thursday (8 October).

Jokowi said some systems allow students to move from secondary school to university, while others offer a pathway programme before entry to diploma or undergraduate courses.

“Some follow a route like ours: primary school, junior high, then secondary school, and then university. But there are also systems that use a pathway programme before moving on to a diploma or bachelor’s degree. I think every country has a different system,” he said.

Jokowi stressed that Gibran had completed an undergraduate degree. In his view, someone who had completed a bachelor’s degree would necessarily have passed the previous educational stages.

“And the most important thing is that the Vice-President has completed a bachelor’s degree. To complete that, he must have passed the earlier stages. Here, that would mean completing senior high school. Otherwise, he could not have enrolled in a bachelor’s degree,” said Jokowi, Gibran’s father.

Jokowi said he respected the Constitutional Court’s decision, the process and its legal reasoning. “We respect the court’s ruling and the stages involved, including the legal considerations it has given. Most importantly, we all respect our Constitution,” he said.

The petitioners who challenged Gibran’s educational eligibility in the 2024 presidential election said they would seek his impeachment through the House after their case was rejected. Jokowi said they were free to pursue that course.

“Our country has democratic mechanisms that must be followed. So they should follow the available democratic mechanisms, in accordance with the Constitution and the applicable laws,” he said.

Sukabumi deputy council speaker removes Gibran’s photograph

The fallout from the Constitutional Court ruling also reached local government. Rojab Asy’ari, deputy speaker of the Sukabumi City Regional House of Representatives and a member of the PDI-P faction, removed Gibran’s photograph from his office.

Rojab said he felt embarrassed by a vice-president who, in his view, had still not been able to prove in court that he held a valid high-school-equivalent qualification.

“This is in response to the facts presented in court yesterday concerning the Constitutional Court ruling. The court records stated that Gibran Rakabuming Raka could not prove that he had a high-school-equivalent certificate,” Rojab said in his office, as reported by detikJabar on Wednesday (7 October).

“Even though that was not proven in the proceedings, as a deputy speaker from the PDI-P faction I feel embarrassed. As a political gesture, I have temporarily taken Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s photograph down from my office,” he added.

He stressed that the photograph’s removal was temporary, pending further legal findings confirming that Gibran’s certificate was valid. The photograph had been handed to the Regional House secretariat.

“Until there is another legal finding stating that Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s certificate is legally valid. We have handed it over to the Regional House secretariat for safekeeping. This is temporary and applies only to my office,” he said.

The PDI-P’s West Java branch said Rojab had acted personally.

“As he himself has said, this was his personal position and action. There was no instruction from the party, whether from the branch, provincial or central board. According to him, it was entirely a personal decision,” West Java PDI-P chair Ono Surono said, as reported by detikJabar on Thursday (8 October).

Ono said Rojab’s action might reflect a personal response to public reaction following the Constitutional Court ruling. He said the party as an institution had not taken a position on the matter.

“Perhaps this is a response not only from him but also from members of the public to the court’s decision. But institutionally, we have not taken a position on this from the outset,” he said.

Ono said PDI-P had no interest in the issue, adding that several central board officials had made the same point.

“According to several central board officials, PDI-P has no interest in this matter,” he said.

NasDem says purported impeachment proposal is a hoax

Following the Constitutional Court ruling, a letter proposing Gibran’s impeachment circulated. NasDem treasurer Ahmad Sahroni said a document attributed to Tonny Tesar, a member of the House from NasDem, was false.

The document, which was seen by the outlet, asked the House to act on the court’s findings by removing Gibran as Vice-President. It cited the requirement that presidential and vice-presidential candidates must have completed at least senior high school or an equivalent level of education.

“[We ask] the leadership of the House of Representatives to bring this fundamental matter to a plenary session and exercise its oversight, interpellation, inquiry or expression-of-opinion rights to investigate the validity of the administrative documents for Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s candidacy,” the document said.

It also called for Gibran’s impeachment to be processed under the constitutional mechanisms set out in the 1945 Constitution and House rules, and referred to the Constitutional Court for a legal ruling.

Sahroni, who is also deputy chair of House Commission III, said no such document existed and described the report as a hoax.

“Hoax, hoax. There’s nothing, there’s nothing,” Sahroni said at the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta.

He said NasDem respected the Constitutional Court’s ruling but had not yet decided its position on the controversy, and was waiting for guidance from party chair Surya Paloh.

“We respect the Constitutional Court process. We haven’t received guidance from the chairman and haven’t been called in. Perhaps later, but not yet. Things remain calm for now,” Sahroni said.

“We’ll wait for the chairman’s direction,” he added.

More from 9 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/fallout-from-constitutional-court-ruling-on-vice-president-gibrans-educational-qualifications-1791503484)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8698871/dinamika-usai-putusan-mk-soal-ijazah-wapres-gibran), translated from Indonesian
Print