Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Experts Highlight the Dangers of Misinterpreting 'Assets Inconsistent with Profile' in the Asset Forfeiture Bill

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Experts Highlight the Dangers of Misinterpreting 'Assets Inconsistent with Profile' in the Asset Forfeiture Bill
Image: Media Indonesia

The Commission III of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) received input from legal experts regarding the discussion of the Asset Forfeiture Bill (RUU Perampasan Aset), particularly on the mechanism for handling assets that are disproportionate to their owner’s profile. Experts warn that this regulation should not open the door to excessive interpretations in practice.

Criminal Law academic from the Faculty of Law at Tarumanagara University, Heri Firmansyah, assesses that the issue of assets inconsistent with profile is one of the crucial points in the bill.

“Then there are other assets as substitutes for assets confiscated by the state, assets that are disproportionate to the profile. This is interesting; we’re talking about unexplained wealth, something that can be quantified in terms of wealth, but the question is where it came from. It seems like there’s an entry point for law enforcement there,” said Heri during the Working Meeting for Public Hearing (RDPU) at the DPR RI, Jakarta, on Monday (6/4).

According to him, if not regulated in detail, this concept has the potential to be abused. He stresses the importance of legal certainty in formulating the rules.

“This needs to be made clearer, because in criminal law we talk about the principles of legality: lex scripta, lex certa, and lex stricta. It must be firm and clear; there should be no interpretations that take law enforcement off track,” he stated.

This input immediately received a response from the Deputy Chairman of Commission III of the DPR, Ahmad Sahroni, who questioned the application of that concept in practice.

“If what was mentioned earlier is assets disproportionate to the profile, for example, a poor person but with major corruption, and then the assets are to be confiscated, how is the perspective on that?” asked Sahroni.

In response, Heri emphasised that the mechanism for determining assets inconsistent with profile should not be left to one party alone, but must go through a clear process involving various institutions.

“This must go through a clear mechanism. Who has the authority to determine it? Is it just the investigator, or does it involve other parties like banking? Because this is cross-institutional and cannot be based on just one viewpoint,” he explained.

He also mentioned the possibility of involving the PPATK to assess whether an asset is classified as a suspicious transaction or not.

“Does everything have to go through the PPATK so it can be seen as a suspicious transaction, or can the investigator directly conclude? This needs to be regulated specifically,” he added.

Heri warns that without firm regulations, the issue of assets inconsistent with profile could lead to lengthy debates in the field, including regarding parties who are actually innocent.

“Many cases become debates because each side feels they have a basis. Even the term innocent owner could emerge; they have assets but no wrongdoing. In criminal law, mens rea is important,” he asserted.

He hopes that Commission III of the DPR can formulate comprehensive regulations so that asset forfeiture efforts remain effective without neglecting principles of justice and legal certainty.

More from 6 April 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/experts-highlight-the-dangers-of-misinterpreting-assets-inconsistent-with-profile-in-the-asset-forfeiture-bill-1775638364)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/876586/pakar-soroti-bahaya-salah-tafsir-aset-tak-sesuai-profil-di-ruu-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian
Print