Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert Warns DPR: Last-Minute Election Bill Debate Could Destroy Public Trust

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Expert Warns DPR: Last-Minute Election Bill Debate Could Destroy Public Trust
Image: Media Indonesia

The deliberation and enactment of the Election Bill (RUU Pemilu) is considered impossible to postpone any further. Beyond following up on a series of Constitutional Court rulings, the revision of electoral regulations is also needed so that Indonesia has a legal foundation capable of anticipating technological developments and ensuring certainty in the organisation of the 2029 general election.

Titi Anggraini, an electoral law expert at the University of Indonesia, warned that delays in deliberation would only result in regulations being drafted hastily once again, with the potential to erode the quality of democracy. In her view, the current stagnation in deliberating the revision of the Election Law shows that neither the House of Representatives (DPR) nor the government has made a strong political commitment to making electoral reform a priority.

“This delay shows the weak willingness and political commitment of the DPR and the government to make electoral reform a priority. Yet the revision of the Election Law is not a need that arose suddenly. The evaluation of the 2024 election, the various Constitutional Court rulings, and the need to design the 2029 election have already provided a very solid basis to begin deliberations immediately,” Titi told Media Indonesia on Wednesday (29 July).

According to her, political factors are indeed one cause of the slow deliberation, because changes to the Election Law directly touch the interests of political parties and the configuration of power. However, this must not be used as an excuse to keep delaying the legislative process.

“Political factors are very dominant because changes to the Election Law directly intersect with party interests and the configuration of power. However, political complexity cannot be used as a reason for continued delay. On the contrary, deliberations must begin earlier so they can proceed transparently, participatively and on the basis of evaluation, and are not once again rushed as the election stages approach,” she said.

Furthermore, Titi reminded that there is another equally important urgency: the selection process for members of the General Election Commission (KPU) and the Election Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu), which will begin shortly. In her view, the formation of electoral administrators must align with the institutional design that will ultimately be set out in the new Election Law.

“The KPU and Bawaslu members must not be selected based on the old institutional design, only for the rules, powers, or institutional structure to change after they are chosen. That risks creating uncertainty and undermining the independence of the administrators,” she asserted.

Titi argued that if the revision of the Election Law is only completed shortly before the 2029 election, Indonesia risks repeating the same problems as in previous elections, namely the birth of reactive and ill-prepared regulations.

“Delaying until close to the 2029 election will once again produce legislation that is reactive, rushed, and highly vulnerable to being pulled by short-term political interests,” she said.

She explained that the impact of such delays would be felt not only by electoral administrators but also by election participants and voters.

“Administrators will lose time to draft technical regulations, prepare human resources, build technology systems, and carry out adequate voter education and socialisation,” she said.

Meanwhile, election participants would lose legal certainty in planning their candidacy strategies and political competition, while the public risks confusion due to rule changes socialised too late.

“For election participants, late rule changes will disrupt certainty in determining candidacy and competition strategies. For voters, rules that keep changing or are poorly socialised can cause confusion. These conditions ultimately increase the potential for disputes, inconsistent implementation, and declining public trust,” Titi said.

For that reason, she argued, electoral law should be an instrument that provides certainty, not one that creates uncertainty in the run-up to the election stages.

“Electoral law should provide stability and certainty, not become a source of uncertainty. Therefore, the principle that rules must be in place well before the stages begin must be upheld. An election with integrity cannot possibly be prepared through regulations made at the last minute,” she said.

Titi further stressed that revising the Election Law is also imperative to accommodate the various Constitutional Court rulings that have changed the design of the national electoral system. In her view, lawmakers cannot simply paste the Court’s rulings into the regulations in a piecemeal fashion.

“The various Constitutional Court rulings have changed important parts of the electoral design and must be followed up consistently by the legislature. Court rulings must not simply be patched partially onto the Election Law. All their implications must be harmonised so as not to create conflicting and ambiguous norms, legal vacuums, or new problems in implementation,” she explained.

Beyond adapting to legal developments, the revision of the Election Law is also considered necessary to respond to the challenges of rapid technological change. Titi said the new regulation needs to comprehensively govern the use of technology in election administration, including transparency, cyber security, and personal data protection.

“The law needs to provide a clear framework on system transparency, cyber security, personal data protection, technology audits, algorithmic accountability, public access, and accountability mechanisms in the event of system failure. Technology must be a tool to strengthen the integrity and accessibility of elections, not create dark spaces that are difficult to oversee,” she said.

She warned that without regulatory renewal, Indonesia risks entering the 2029 election with rules that are no longer relevant to legal and technological developments.

“If the DPR and the government do not prioritise this renewal, we risk holding the 2029 election with fragmented rules, lagging behind technological developments, and not fully aligned with the Constitutional Court’s rulings. The impact would not merely be technical; it could also erode the legitimacy of the election results and public trust in democracy,” she said.

Therefore, Titi urged the DPR to promptly finalise the academic manuscript and draft of the Election Bill so that deliberation with the government can begin openly and with public participation.

“Therefore, the DPR must immediately complete the academic manuscript and the draft Election Bill so deliberation can begin with the government in an open, measured and participatory manner. The remaining time should be used to produce substantive reform, not as an excuse to delay again or maintain the status quo,” she asserted.

Titi added that accelerating the revision is also important because several Constitutional Court rulings explicitly order the legislature to take follow-up action.

These include Constitutional Court Ruling Number 116/PUU-XXI/2023 on the reconstruction of the parliamentary threshold, Ruling Number 135/PUU-XXII/2024 on separating the simultaneous national election from simultaneous regional elections, and Ruling Number 120/PUU-XX/2022, which mandates that the selection of electoral administrators be completed before the election stages begin.

In her view, all these rulings must be accommodated in full in the revision of the Election Law so that the 2029 election has legal certainty, is aligned with the constitution, and is able to safeguard the integrity of democracy.

More from 29 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-warns-dpr-last-minute-election-bill-debate-could-destroy-public-trust-1785307834)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/915916/pakar-ingatkan-dpr-bahas-ruu-pemilu-di-menit-terakhir-bisa-hancurkan-kepercayaan-publik), translated from Indonesian
Print