Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert Urges Caution over Asset Forfeiture, Even in Countries that Pioneered It

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Expert Urges Caution over Asset Forfeiture, Even in Countries that Pioneered It
Image: detikcom

Open Parliament Institute Executive Director Yadi Surya Diputra has highlighted challenges in implementing asset forfeiture in several countries. He said that even countries that pioneered the practice continue to face difficulties.

Yadi made the remarks at a public hearing with Commission III of the House of Representatives (DPR) on Tuesday (27 October 2026). He said he had conducted research covering 78 countries.

“Some have adopted it in full, some only partially; some have expanded it, while others have imposed limits. Looking at current practice, does enacting this law in various countries really result in large-scale asset recovery?” Yadi said at the hearing in the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Tuesday (27 October).

Yadi said implementation remained complex in the five countries that pioneered the approach. The United States, he noted, had revised its law several times.

“First, the United States. It is one of the five original pioneer countries, alongside the United Kingdom, Ireland, Italy and Australia. Even these early pioneers are now struggling after passing the law,” he said.

Yadi said asset forfeiture often led to disputes between central and federal authorities. He also urged caution over providing compensation to law-enforcement officers.

“This leads to agencies competing with one another and, in the United States, to disputes between states, because there is compensation and revenue-sharing,” he said.

The United Kingdom once established an agency to recover assets, but it did not perform effectively and was eventually dissolved.

“When it was established, the asset-recovery body was given €65 million in funding, but its asset-recovery proceeds amounted to only €23 million. That led to its dissolution and the creation of a new model in the UK,” he said.

Yadi cited a similar imbalance in the UK, where the costs exceeded the value of assets recovered. In Italy, meanwhile, the value of seized assets declined.

“Italy is an interesting case, and one that should make us cautious. In Italy, 95 per cent of seized assets lost value, falling to zero,” he said.

More from 27 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-urges-caution-over-asset-forfeiture-even-in-countries-that-pioneered-it-1793098418)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8726533/pakar-soroti-perampasan-aset-di-negara-inisiator-bicara-kehati-hatian), translated from Indonesian
Print