Expert Suggests Child-Friendly Features on Social Media Instead of Age Restrictions
What matters most is ensuring the enforcement of rules that protect children.
Indonesia has implemented an age restriction barring children under 16 from owning social media accounts. Hosea Immanuel Latumahina, a researcher at the Center for Digital Society (CfDS) at Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM), said no country has truly succeeded in specifically implementing such a policy, with the United Kingdom and the European Union still at the planning stage.
“We need to question what the main reason is — is it simply because of the dominant narrative driven by comparisons with other countries? It would be quite concerning if this were a reactive policy,” Hosea explained on Friday (17 July).
According to CfDS research, other countries have very specific and measurable focuses. He cited Australia, which focuses on minimising negative impacts rather than imposing rigid access restrictions, while China and Vietnam target the duration of online gaming rather than closing off social media access entirely.
Indonesia, by contrast, has taken a step that combines all of these dimensions at once: fully restricting access, minimising negative impacts, and preventing destructive cases simultaneously.
This approach, he argued, makes Indonesia’s policy extremely complex and risks killing off children’s digital rights.
The aim of restricting internet access for children under 16 is to curb the prevalence of cyberbullying, digital addiction and cognitive decline. However, he said children will seek loopholes by manipulating age verification. This practice, in fact, degrades the credibility of the national digital security system.
Secondly, when major platforms are blocked, children are likely to switch to underground platforms that have no security systems or age verification whatsoever.
Thirdly, the policy risks castrating children’s rights to participate, express themselves and access healthy information in the digital space — rights guaranteed by the United Nations.
“Moreover, digital security issues in Indonesia, such as data leaks and cyberbullying, are actually systemic and affect all age groups, not just children under 16,” he added.
He explained that restricting children without equipping them with information-filtering skills will only postpone the problem. Once children pass the age of 16, they will be exposed to a digital storm without any preparation.
His side has urged the government to introduce industry standardisation. Platforms must be required to provide built-in child-centric features from the outset, such as automatic privacy modes and strict parental controls. The government has also been urged to integrate the curriculum, embedding digital literacy and ethics materials into the official school syllabus. (H-4)
The UGM expert considers that restricting social media access for children under 16 through the Tunas Government Regulation has a positive impact on literacy skills and academic achievement.
TikTok has officially deactivated 780,000 accounts belonging to children under 16 to comply with the Tunas regulation. Minister of Communications and Digital Affairs Meutya Hafid welcomed the move and issued a warning to other platforms.
Exposure to social media at too young an age risks disrupting emotional regulation, identity formation, and the quality of real social interactions.
From early childhood to early adolescence, children still need concrete experiences to develop their cognitive, socio-emotional and psychomotor abilities.
Appropriate restrictions, rather than total prohibition, can reduce the risks of overstimulation from instant content, social anxiety caused by constant self-comparison, and exposure to danger.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-suggests-child-friendly-features-on-social-media-instead-of-age-restrictions-1784307028)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/912035/ahli-saran-ada-fitur-ramah-anak-di-medsos-alih-alih-pembatasan-usia), translated from Indonesian