Expert Says Revision of Election Law a Constitutional Necessity, Here's Why
Election Law expert from the University of Indonesia (UI), Titi Anggrainability, has emphasised that the revision of Law Number 7 of 2017 concerning General Elections (Election Law) has now become a legal necessity and an urgent constitutional task for the House of Representatives (DPR) and the Government. This is based on the fact that the Constitutional Court (MK) has granted 22 judicial review decisions that alter the anatomy of the Election Law.
Titi believes that the high number of MK decisions means the current face of Indonesian election law requires a thorough overhaul, rather than just partial changes. Comprehensive changes are necessary so that all court decisions can be accommodated harmoniously, holistically, and without overlap.
“The lawmakers do not actually need to start from scratch because the architecture and constitutional framework of our election law have already been outlined by the MK. The task of the DPR and the Government now is to discuss the implementation aspects so that it is operative and can be executed with quality,” said Titi during a public discussion titled “Delaying the Election Law Revision and the Threat of Constitutional Disobedience” held by Perludem in Jakarta on Sunday (28/6/2026).
Titi explained that there are at least two new regulations following the MK decisions that must be immediately and concretely addressed by lawmakers in the latest revision draft. First, regarding the abolition of the Presidential Threshold. Based on MK Decision Number 62/PUU-XXII/2024, the minimum requirement of 20% of DPR seats or 25% of the national valid vote has been officially abolished.
The MK stated that all political parties participating in the election have the right to propose candidate pairs. The DPR is now tasked with drafting technical regulations to prevent monopolies or the hoarding of support by certain political forces, in order to guarantee a diversity of choices for the people.
The second regulation concerns the reconstruction of the Parliamentary Threshold. Following up on MK Decision Number 116/PUU-XXIII/2023, the 4% threshold figure only applies to the 2024 Election and must be changed for subsequent elections. A new formula must be designed to ensure that valid votes are not wasted, to reduce the disproportionality of results, and to remain aligned with the spirit of simplifying the party system.
Titi reminded that the discussions should not merely be for the consumption of political elites in closed rooms involving only faction leaders or general chairpersons of certain parties. She noted that in its ruling, the MK ordered that the drafting of these new rules must prioritise the principle of meaningful participation.
The DPR is required to open doors for input and involve non-parliamentary political parties that do not hold seats in the DPR, alongside listening to the broader aspirations of civil society.
Furthermore, Titi warned that the DPR must move quickly to discuss this Election Law Revision, especially since there is currently no academic paper related to the law. Titi highlighted the slow movement of the DPR and the Government up to mid-2026. She expressed concern regarding the political pragmatism between the legislature and the executive leading up to the 2024 Election. On 9 March 2021, the DPR, along with the Government and the DPD, actually agreed to remove the Election Law Revision from the National Legislation Programme (Prolegnas) list.
“Regarding today’s situation, why does this serve as a very harsh constitutional warning for us? Besides the lessons we learned leading up to 2024, we are seeing the symptoms of how political pragmatism between the legislature and the president led to stagnation, a lack of legal renewal, or the maintenance of the status quo in 2024,” she said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-says-revision-of-election-law-a-constitutional-necessity-heres-why-1782658228)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/905263/pakar-sebut-revisi-uu-pemilu-jadi-keniscayaan-konstitusional-ini-alasannya), translated from Indonesian