Expert Says KPPU Must Consider OJK Authority in Online Lending Interest Rate Dispute
The fate of honorary teachers has become increasingly distressing.
The appeal hearing against the ruling of the Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) on the online lending (pindar) industry at the Central Jakarta Commercial Court again presented an expert in State Administrative Law from Padjadjaran University, Adrian Rompis, on Thursday (13/8). During the hearing, Adrian explained that verbal orders issued by the government can have a legal basis from the perspective of government administration law.
“If we look at Law 30 of 2014, it is fluid because it talks about government administration, it is very fluid. Verbal orders are allowed. What is not allowed is if they are then challenged and made into a problem at the Administrative Court,” he explained.
According to Adrian, government administration law recognises a number of aspects that can be used to assess the legality of a government action, including authority and procedure. Therefore, the provision of direction or orders by the government to other parties, including business actors, needs to be viewed based on the authority attached to the institution.
During the hearing, one of the petitioners’ legal representatives again raised the President’s mandate to the Financial Services Authority (OJK) to regulate the development of the digital economy industry that began to grow in Indonesia around 2016.
Responding to this, Adrian said that if the President as the holder of executive power gives direction to an authority in the financial sector, this cannot be separated from the public interest that is intended to be protected.
As context, in 2018 OJK was said to have given a verbal order to the Indonesian Joint Funding Fintech Association (AFPI) to regulate the maximum economic benefit limit for online lending through the association’s code of conduct. The policy was intended to protect consumers from high interest burdens.
When the case was subsequently processed by KPPU, OJK through a press release dated 20 May 2025 had conveyed the existence of this direction. However, KPPU still imposed a total fine of Rp755 billion on 97 online lending platforms because it considered that OJK’s verbal direction could not be used as a basis for regulating interest rate limits.
Adrian also highlighted the obligation of business actors to comply with the association’s code of conduct, which contains provisions regarding the maximum economic benefit limit for online lending. According to him, if the regulator requires association membership as part of the process of obtaining a business licence, then that membership is not entirely a voluntary choice for business actors.
“It (association membership) will become a legal obligation if the regulator then issues what is called its juridical instrument, namely a licence. So if he (the businessman) does not have a licence, he is not allowed to conduct business activities. This requirement will be the capital for OJK to supervise this industry,” he said.
Furthermore, Adrian emphasised that every state institution has authority sourced from its founding law. In this case, KPPU’s authority, according to him, needs to be viewed together with OJK’s authority as the regulator of the financial services sector.
When asked by the petitioners’ legal counsel about the possibility of another state institution annulling the validity of OJK’s verbal order to business actors, Adrian said that such an action cannot be carried out arbitrarily without a basis of authority.
According to him, a state institution cannot correct or take over the actions of another institution if it does not have the authority granted by laws and regulations.
“If an institution ‘meddles’ to regulate, ‘meddles’ to make a decision, that becomes, in the terminology of state administrative law, legal engineering. We can possibly say that its action is ultra vires, if it does not have the authority,” he told the panel.
OJK as the regulator intervened by asking the association to lower interest rates to a reasonable level that does not strangle consumers.
KPPU is advised to take into account the motive of compliance and the goal of protecting consumers, so as not to create an erroneous legal precedent for the online lending industry.
A study by Core Indonesia shows that the use of peer-to-peer (P2P) lending fintech, or online loans (pinjol), is dominated by business purposes.
The Financial Services Authority (OJK) has emphasised that the setting of maximum interest rate limits on online loan (pinjol) platforms is intended to protect the public.
This interest rate cap policy has also been regulated and supervised by the Financial Services Authority (OJK) for a long time, as part of consumer protection efforts.
Agusman said that providers continue to be encouraged to strengthen credit scoring and risk management in the distribution of funding.
Kredivo stated that it will continue its internal investigation even though the handling process by law enforcement officials has been completed.
Digital financial services are increasingly becoming part of the daily activities of Indonesian society.
Low digital literacy and financial literacy remain one of the main causes of people easily becoming victims of illegal online loans.
OJK and the PASTI Task Force are strengthening cross-sector synergy to suppress the rise of fraudulent investments and illegal online loans (pinjol) in the East Priangan region.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-says-kppu-must-consider-ojk-authority-in-online-lending-interest-rate-dispute-1787233900)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/924123/pakar-nilai-kppu-perlu-perhatikan-kewenangan-ojk-dalam-sengketa-bunga-pindar), translated from Indonesian