Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert Says Health Concerns Over Polycarbonate Reusable Gallons Lack Clinical Evidence

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Business
Expert Says Health Concerns Over Polycarbonate Reusable Gallons Lack Clinical Evidence
Image: Media Indonesia

Concerns over the health risks of reused polycarbonate (PC) water gallons have been deemed deliberately circulated without a solid basis. Chemistry expert from the Bandung Institute of Technology (ITB), Dr Handajaya Rusli, M.Si., asserted that new regulations concerning these containers are not urgent. According to him, public worries so far remain merely theoretical potential without concrete clinical evidence.

“All this time, the narrative has only been about its potential to increase because of this and that. But those are factors they merely heard from others — no one has ever been able to prove it until now,” said Handajaya.

He explained that, fundamentally, all chemical compounds that make up plastics possess toxic properties. However, the public need not worry, as strict oversight by the Food and Drug Supervisory Agency (BPOM) and independent testing by manufacturers are carried out in multiple layers before plastic containers are permitted to circulate in the market.

Handajaya signalled that the surfacing of the Bisphenol A (BPA) hazard issue is closely linked to business competition within the bottled drinking water (AMDK) industry. This is evident from the timing of the issue’s emergence, which coincided with the arrival of alternative gallon containers made of Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET), or single-use gallons.

“Sometimes these issues emerge once an alternative already exists. For instance, the polycarbonate gallon now has a replacement, namely the PET gallon. So it is essentially business competition,” he said.

Ironically, Handajaya instead highlighted the public’s habit of repeatedly using single-use gallons, a practice that is highly dangerous to health. He frequently finds single-use gallon containers used by vendors until their colour turns yellowish.

Echoing this view, a researcher from the Department of Food Science and Technology and the SEAFAST Center at IPB University, Nugraha Edhi Suyatma, outlined the technical advantages of reusable polycarbonate gallons over single-use (PET) ones. Functionally, polycarbonate is far more flexible and resistant to the risk of shattering or cracking.

One of the key advantage parameters lies in the Glass Transition Temperature (Tg). The higher the Tg value, the more resistant the container is to high temperatures during washing or distribution.

“This condition allows reusable gallons to be washed in hot water at 60–80 degrees Celsius with scrubbing using a plastic brush without causing damage to the container’s surface,” Nugraha explained.

Responding to this polemic, BPOM chief Taruna Ikrar affirmed that reusable gallon containers currently circulating in society are entirely safe for use. BPOM continues to conduct strict oversight of the food packaging safety standards of AMDK producers.

Taruna emphasised that every product that has obtained a distribution permit from BPOM is guaranteed to meet safety requirements, including compliance with the Indonesian National Standard (SNI). “Yes, it is certainly safe — anything already licensed by BPOM is definitely safe. Because one of BPOM’s requirements for issuing a permit is that the container has SNI certification. So all SNI-certified containers are safe,” he concluded.

More from 16 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-says-health-concerns-over-polycarbonate-reusable-gallons-lack-clinical-evidence-1784199080)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/911565/pakar-sebut-isu-bahaya-galon-guna-ulang-polikarbonat-tidak-punya-bukti-klinis), translated from Indonesian
Print