Expert opposes reverse burden of proof in asset seizure bill
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Taufik Rahman, a legal expert from Airlable Airlangga University (Unair), has stated his disagreement with the application of the reverse burden of proof method to determine assets to be seized from criminal activities, as currently being considered in the Asset Seizure Bill (RUU Perampasan Aset).
According to him, under this method, the burden of proving that assets are linked to a criminal act is placed upon the defendant. However, he believes this contradicts the principle of a fair trial.
“Therefore, the burden of proof I am referring to should remain with law enforcement agencies. Personally, I do not agree with the burden being reversed through the use of reverse burden of proof; I do not agree,” said Taufik during a meeting with Commission III of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) at the parliamentary complex, Jakarta, on Monday.
He stated that an asset should only be seized if a court ruling declares that the asset has a very strong connection to a specific criminal act.
Meanwhile, he noted that the reverse burden of proof method creates opportunities for asset seizure even when the connection between the asset and a specific crime is doubtful.
He assessed that implementing such a method has the potential to place the defendant in an unbalanced position, as the defendant must face a state that possesses significantly greater resources and authority.
Furthermore, he believes that the reverse burden of proof method opens loopholes for the abuse of power, given that the legal strength of the defendant is far lower than that of the state.
Consequently, he proposed that the Asset Seizure Bill should clearly regulate the standards of proof in non-conviction-based asset seizure cases. In this regard, Taufik suggested that the link between an asset and a criminal act should be proven using the ‘clear and convincing evidence’ standard.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-opposes-reverse-burden-of-proof-in-asset-seizure-bill-1791208630)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5772308/pakar-tidak-setuju-beban-pembuktian-terbalik-dalam-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian