Expert: MPR Visit to MK and MA Could Intervene in Judicial Independence
Constitutional law expert Bivitri Susanti has criticised the move by the leadership of the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) to visit the Constitutional Court (MK) and the Supreme Court (MA). According to her, such meetings carry the risk of creating the impression of interference in judicial institutions that ought to be independent and free from the influence of other state bodies.
Bivitri stressed that, under the constitutional system, the Supreme Court and Constitutional Court occupy a position that must be protected from any form of interference, whether through memoranda of understanding or meetings that could compromise institutional independence.
“Moreover, the Supreme Court and Constitutional Court are judicial institutions which, in theory, must never be intervened in or bound by MoUs, in whatever form,” Bivitri told journalists on Tuesday (14 July).
She emphasised that judges at both institutions must be given the space to decide cases independently, without pressure or direction from other institutions. “Let them make their decisions according to the cases that come before them. There should be no intervention, and no need for advice in the form of courtesy visits from other institutions,” she said.
Bivitri assessed two possible motives behind the MPR leadership’s visits to the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court. The first, she said, could be a desire to restore the MPR’s image as the highest state institution, as it was before the amendments to the 1945 Constitution.
“The MPR, particularly its leadership, wants to be regarded as a separate institution, the highest state institution as before the amendment,” she said.
Yet, Bivitri noted, following the constitutional amendments the MPR is no longer the highest state institution. It merely exercises the powers set out in Article 3 of the 1945 Constitution: amending and enacting the Constitution, inaugurating the President and Vice-President, and dismissing the President and/or Vice-President in accordance with constitutional mechanisms.
She also reminded that the MPR leadership consists of members of the House of Representatives (DPR) or Regional Representative Council (DPD) who perform the MPR’s functions only when it is in session, and therefore hold no special authority to build institutional relations with the judiciary.
“All the MPR leaders we elect are members of the DPR or DPD. So they actually do not have such authority,” she said.
The second possibility Bivitri highlighted was an attempt to weaken the independence of the judiciary. She said this suspicion was reinforced by the signing of a memorandum of understanding concerning copies of court rulings following the MPR’s visit to the Constitutional Court.
“The second possibility is that there is indeed a desire to weaken the judiciary, because the DPR itself is already weak — as we know, seven of the eight factions in the DPR are all part of the KIM Plus coalition,” she said.
Bivitri also argued that if a similar step had been taken directly by the President, the potential for public criticism would have been far greater. She therefore suspects the MPR has been positioned to carry out this agenda while projecting the image of being the highest state institution. “Perhaps what is happening now is the use of the MPR, with the portrayal that it is still the highest state institution. But in my view it remains wrong. Both the first and second motivations stem from a mistaken understanding of the MPR’s position,” she asserted.
She further reminded that every state institution must carry out its functions in accordance with the powers granted by the constitution. Maintaining distance between the branches of power, she said, is an essential condition for preserving the independence of the judiciary and the principle of the rule of law. She reaffirmed that judicial independence is a vital foundation for Indonesia as a state governed by law.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-mpr-visit-to-mk-and-ma-could-intervene-in-judicial-independence-1784109093)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/911166/pakar-kunjungan-mpr-ke-mk-dan-ma-berpotensi-intervensi-independensi-yudikatif), translated from Indonesian