Expert: Identification of Forest and Land Fire Perpetrators Must Be Based on Investigation
Fire expert Raffles Panjasting asserts that the identification of perpetrators in forest and land fires (karhutla) must be based on accountable investigation results. The presence of fire within a concession area does not automatically prove that the permit holder is the party responsible for the burning.
Raffles stated that investigations need to differentiate between the location of the burnt land and the party that caused the fire. According to him, the presence of fire is a fact that requires further examination to determine the initial ignition point, the time of the incident, the spread pattern, and evidence linking the fire to a specific party.
“The statement that a fire occurred within a concession is different from the statement that a company burned the concession. The first statement describes the location of the incident, whereas the second alleges an action that must be proven,” Raffles said in a statement in Jakarta on Wednesday (23/9/2026).
He explained that investigations must also test various possible ignition sources, whether originating from inside or outside the concession. Every possibility, he noted, must be treated as a hypothesis requiring proof, rather than being used as a conclusion from the outset.
“Fire does not follow administrative or permit boundaries. Therefore, the area that ultimately burns is not always the same as the initial ignition point. The connection between the two must be traced through field evidence and chronology,” he added.
According to Raffles, analyses of wind conditions, fuel, spread patterns, witness statements, and the timing of fire discovery and handling can be used to reconstruct the incident. All this data must be read in an integrated manner so that the determination of the cause and the perpetrator does not rely solely on a single image or a single coordinate point.
Geospatial expert Asep Karsidi added that the overlap of hotspots with concession maps is merely an indication for further examination. Satellite data has specific characteristics and measurement limitations, meaning the heat detection coordinates in certain products cannot be immediately treated as the exact position of the ignition source.
“Maps can help identify in which area fire indications were detected. However, maps cannot stand alone to determine who started the fire or whether there was intent,” said Asep.
Asep stated that analysis must utilise valid concession boundary maps, time-stamped data, and sequential satellite imagery. The results of such analysis must then be matched with field inspections, particularly when fire indications are located near the boundaries of management areas.
In handling forest and land fires, he noted, it is necessary to distinguish between the location of the incident, the cause of the fire, the perpetrator, and the company’s responsibility. Through evidence-based investigation, the information received by the public can be more complete, and the law enforcement process can remain focused on proof and environmental protection.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-identification-of-forest-and-land-fire-perpetrators-must-be-based-on-investigation-1790171770)
Originally published by Republika (https://ekonomi.republika.co.id/berita/tltjsa522/pakar-penetapan-pelaku-karhutla-harus-berdasarkan-penyelidikan), translated from Indonesian