Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert Highlights Parties Most Responsible for Gibran's Diploma Controversy

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Expert Highlights Parties Most Responsible for Gibran's Diploma Controversy
Image: CNN Indonesia

Political expert and Director of SCL Taktika Konsultan, Iqbal Themi, has responded to the Constitutional Court’s (MK) decision regarding the lawsuit challenging the validity of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational requirements during the 2024 Presidential Election, which was ruled inadmissible.

In its considerations, the Constitutional Court also stated that there was no evidence that Gibran possesses a diploma proving he completed overseas education equivalent to Senior High School (SMA) or its equivalent.

Iqbal noted that the political issue arising from this ruling is no longer merely about whether the diploma is authentic or fake, but rather how the educational requirements for the Vice Presidential candidate were verified during the 2024 Election.

“Following the Constitutional Court’s decision, I see that this issue is no longer solely about whether Gibran’s diploma is real or fake. The far more important political question now is, if educational documents are a requirement for nomination, who is actually responsible for ensuring that these requirements are met?” Iqbal stated in a briefing on Wednesday (7/10).

Iqbal believes that the Constitutional Court’s finding—that no documents regarding Gibran’s high school diploma or equivalent were found—justifiably leads the public to question the preceding processes.

“When the Constitutional Court, after examining the evidence and trial facts, fails to find convincing documents as proof of high school-level graduation, the public is politically entitled to question how the verification process was conducted from the start,” he said.

He argued that the issue should not be directed solely at Gibran personally. Instead, the institutions involved in the educational equivalence process, the verification of nomination requirements, and election oversight must also explain their respective roles.

“Since this concerns a Vice Presidential candidate, the verification standards should be extremely strict. If questions are now arising regarding the underlying documents, then the entire verification chain needs to be explained openly to the public,” he added.

According to him, transparency is essential to maintain the credibility of the system and public trust in the conduct of elections.

“The best way to stop speculation is not through an opinion war, but through transparency. Open the documents used, explain the equivalence and verification processes, so that the public can assess whether the problem lies with the documents, the procedure, the regulation, or indeed a weakness in the verification process,” he said.

Previously, the Constitutional Court decided that the lawsuit regarding the validity of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational requirements during the 2024 Presidential Election could not be accepted.

The decision was read during a hearing for case number: 01/PHPU.PRES-XXI/2024 concerning the Dispute of the 2024 Presidential and Vice Presidential Election Results, held in the Constitutional Court plenary courtroom, Jakarta, on Tuesday (6/10) night.

“Regarding the substance of the petition, the petitioners’ request is inadmissible,” stated the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court, Suhartoyo.

The case was filed by the Independent Committee for Election Monitoring (KIPP), Partai Ummat, former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights Denny Indrayana, and six citizens comprising the Forum of Retired TNI Soldiers, M Subhan, Bonatua Silalahi, and Tiurma MS Sihombing.

During the trial, Denny Indrayana explained that the form of documentation used as a requirement for Gibran’s nomination was only an equivalence certificate issued by the Ministry of Education, rather than proof of graduation or a diploma.

Denny mentioned that the certificate submitted to the General Elections Commission (KPU) as a nomination requirement stated that Gibran studied at UTS Insearch, Sydney, Australia.

The letter stated that Gibran’s education was equivalent to Grade 12 or high school senior year and equivalent to a Vocational High School (SMK) specialising in Accounting. He noted, however, that the letter did not indicate that the individual had actually graduated from the institution.

More from 8 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-highlights-parties-most-responsible-for-gibrans-diploma-controversy-1791402673)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261007150527-32-1412704/pakar-soroti-pihak-yang-paling-bertanggung-jawab-soal-ijazah-gibran), translated from Indonesian
Print