Expert Explains Why Many Jewish People Are Successful and Wealthy
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — Several studies have documented a long history of Jewish people achieving success. In the 20th century, Jewish people in the West became prominent intellectuals and reached the highest economic classes.
Many also received the highest awards in science: the Nobel Prize. Between 1901 and 1962, Jewish people accounted for 16% of Nobel laureates in the sciences. One example is the renowned Jewish physicist Albert Einstein, who won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1921.
According to Paul Burstein’s 2007 study, “Jewish Educational and Economic Success in the United States”, Jewish people in the US have been more successful economically and educationally than other ethnic and racial groups.
So what are the supposed secrets behind Jewish people’s success and their ability to “hold the world in their hands”?
Richard Lynn and Satoshi Kanazawa, in their 2008 paper “How to explain high Jewish achievement”, put forward at least two hypotheses. The first is that Jewish people have above-average intelligence. In his 1919 work “Jewish Contribution to Civilization”, Jacobs wrote that “German Jews are at the summit of European success”.
Jacobs based this view on empirical observations of Jewish success in Europe at the time. However, as intelligence or IQ tests had not yet been developed, the claim could not be considered conclusive.
When IQ testing began to develop in the mid-20th century, the hypothesis that Jewish people had high intelligence—including Jacobs’s assertion—could be assessed against test results. Those results, the article says, indicated that Jewish people did have above-average intelligence.
The second explanation is the strength of cultural values. Lynn and Kanazawa point to a work ethic focused on pursuing success.
In Jewish families, success is seen as something every child in each generation must achieve. As a result, parents expect their children to excel. They provide nutritious food and encourage them to develop a love of reading.
This reflects a belief that literacy is the only way out of ignorance. The article says this is borne out by their experience during the Abbasid Caliphate (750–1258 CE).
According to the 2012 study “The Chosen Few: How Education Shaped Jewish History”, Jewish people experienced the traumatic destruction of a temple during that era. This prompted them to learn to read and free themselves from illiteracy.
Once they had acquired literacy, they left their former agricultural occupations and focused on literacy and education. They came to believe these fields could improve their prosperity, and Jewish people subsequently became strongly oriented towards education.
Historian Jerry Z. Muller offers another explanation in Project Syndicate: Jewish success is also closely linked to the discrimination they have experienced, which had two consequences.
First, it fostered strong connections among Jewish people. These networks opened up opportunities: people knew one another and could start new jobs and businesses.
Second, discrimination encouraged them to seek out new opportunities that others overlooked, helping them improve their circumstances. Over time, they entered trading or developed new inventions that had not previously been considered.
On the creativity involved in producing new inventions, Burstein’s 2007 study says Jewish people’s scepticism towards conventional local ideas in the places where they lived may have played a role.
By declining to adopt those ideas, Jewish immigrants began thinking creatively and devising new approaches, which could stimulate creativity and intellectual ability. The article says these factors ultimately contributed to economic success.
These are some of the explanations offered for Jewish success. The article argues that anyone can learn from these approaches: achieving success and wealth requires learning from others, regardless of ethnicity, religion or background.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-explains-why-many-jewish-people-are-successful-and-wealthy-1792630253)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/lifestyle/20261021194213-33-778374/ahli-ungkap-alasan-banyak-orang-yahudi-sukses-dan-kaya-raya), translated from Indonesian