Expert: Economic Factors Drive Crime, Job Training Prevents Recidivism
The Executive Director of the Center for Detention Studies (CDS), Gatot Goei, has said that economic factors are among the most common problems found among inmates in correctional facilities and detention centres. Gatot stated that, based on CDS observations, many detainees or prisoners admit to committing crimes or criminal acts because of their financial circumstances.
“Looking at the demographics of criminal offences, it can be said that half of our prison population is incarcerated because of economic factors,” Gatot told detikcom on Thursday (13/8/2026).
Gatot cited the example of inmates involved in low-level narcotics distribution, namely couriers. Based on interviews conducted by CDS, limited job opportunities and low income are often the reasons someone is tempted to join a narcotics network.
“Why would someone be willing to sacrifice themselves to become a drug courier? From our interviews with these couriers, it is indeed because of economic factors, because of employment factors. Limited income makes them tempted to become couriers,” said Gatot.
For this reason, Gatot believes that criminal punishment alone does not necessarily deter a prisoner. When economic problems continue to haunt them, there is potential for inmates to return to a criminal environment.
“So indeed one of the needs of prisoners is actually skills and expertise activities. This is actually conceptually in line with what has been launched by the Minister of Immigration and Corrections, Agus Andrianto,” said Gatot.
Gatot assessed that productive activities and skills training inside prisons have a broader function than merely filling prisoners’ time. Such programmes, he said, can serve as an instrument to reduce negative interactions among prison inmates.
“Why is there a need for skills training activities and work preparation? This can break the chain of the school of crime inside prisons,” Gatot stated.
According to him, prisoners who do not receive guidance and supervision risk acquiring new networks while inside prison. “Couriers who are not supervised and not rehabilitated can come out as bigger dealers. Because inside, they socialise, get new networks and so on,” he said.
Gatot said that marketing systems have so far been an obstacle for the work or skills of prisoners. He gave the example of agricultural and livestock products from prisoners previously facing barriers when trying to be marketed.
“So far, products from prisoners or probation clients have experienced bottlenecks. When they raised cattle, the cattle could not be sold in the market because there are mechanisms for beef to enter the market,” he explained.
In his observations at several prisons, Gatot said he now sees efforts by the Ministry of Immigration and Corrections to connect the results of prisoner activities with the market. Gatot’s statement is based on CDS visits to several prisons.
“My observation at Nusakambangan, which used to be quiet, is now starting to bustle with agricultural and livestock activities, and it is systematic because the workers are prepared from among the prisoners, and the consultants are professionals,” said Gatot.
He said professional elements are also starting to be involved in distribution and marketing. Thus, the production output of prisoners does not stop as a training activity, but has the opportunity to be absorbed by the market.
“Distribution, marketing and so on also involve professional people, so that the goods produced have a market,” he said.
Gatot said CDS is also observing rehabilitation activities in several other regions, including Tanjung Gusta Prison and Langkat Prison in North Sumatra, as well as several correctional units in Tangerang.
Nevertheless, Gatot reminded that skills programmes and work training cannot be applied to all prisoners. He explained that each inmate has different characteristics, risk levels and rehabilitation needs.
“The Ministry of Immigration and Corrections must be able to optimise the separation of those who truly can and want to work, and those who do not want to work, but again it comes back to their lifestyle. However, not all prisoners need interventions in the form of food security or skills. Because some prisoners, for example, are emotional, aggressive, and have a high potential to escape,” he said.
According to him, prisoners with these characteristics require handling that focuses more on personality, psychology and legal compliance aspects before participating in other programmes. “They must be placed in one place and the intervention is sufficient with personality, psychological intervention, legal compliance intervention, and then intervention related to their religion,” Gatot continued.
Gatot said such mapping is important because the prison population is not homogeneous. In fact, according to him, within a single prison there can be prisoners who want to participate in positive activities and groups that are still trying to maintain criminal behaviour.
“There will definitely be a split within one prison or detention centre. There are those who are pro-positive activities, and there are those who want to distribute, want to control, want to influence officers and so on,” he said.
Therefore, Gatot assessed that separation based on risk level and rehabilitation needs is an important part of prison management. “Those who do not want to be invited to participate in positive activities must be specially rehabilitated. There must be separation,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-economic-factors-drive-crime-job-training-prevents-recidivism-1786614903)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8616996/pakar-faktor-ekonomi-dorong-kriminalitas-bekal-kerja-cegah-kejahatan-berulang), translated from Indonesian