Expert: Denny's Lawsuit is a Momentum for the Constitutional Court to Resolve Constitutional Issues
Zainal Arifin Mochtar, a Professor of Constitutional Law at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), stated that Denny Indrayana’s lawsuit regarding the candidacy requirements for Vice President Gibran Rakabasting Raka serves as a momentum for the Constitutional Court (MK) to resolve constitutional issues that have emerged since Decision number 90/PUU-XXI/2023.
According to him, the handling of this lawsuit demonstrates that the Constitutional Court has moved beyond mere formalities and has begun to consider aspects of ‘constitutional importance’.
“If the MK were strictly adhering to the text, this case would not have proceeded. We must admit, this case would not have continued if the MK were strictly adhering to the text,” Zainal told reporters on Wednesday (30/9).
Zainal noted that General Election Result Disputes (PHPU) have a very short timeframe for handling. However, the Constitutional Court decided to proceed with the case filed by Denny and other petitioners through to the evidentiary stage.
“When the MK accepts this PHPU and proceeds to the evidentiary stage, it means the MK intends to address constitutional importance. That is how we interpret it,” he said.
Zainral also touched upon the issue of the petitioners’ legal standing. He believes the Constitutional Court has taken steps to move past formalistic hurdles and enter the substance of the case.
“When the MK steps outside of that and enters the evidentiary process, in my opinion, it deserves a thumbs up as it signifies that the consideration of constitutional importance is occurring,” he added.
Zainal also linked the case to Decision number 90/PUU-XXI/2023, which altered the age requirements for presidential and vice-presidential candidates. That ruling was controversial as it paved the way for Gibran, who was under 40 at the time, to run for the vice presidency.
Zainal assessed that the case currently being examined by the MK could serve as an opportunity for the institution to resolve what he described as a ‘debt’ resulting from that previous decision.
“I believe this is also a ‘debt’, in quotes, that must be paid by the MK itself regarding Decision 90,” said Zainal.
“The debt must be paid in full. And I have great hope that we can make peace with the past through the settlement of this debt by the Constitutional Court,” he continued.
The requirements for Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s candidacy as Vice President in the 2024 Presidential Election have been challenged again in the Constitutional Court.
The petitioners include the Independent Committee for Election Monitoring (KIPP), the Ummat Party, Denny Indrayana, six citizens part of the Forum of TNI Veterans, M Subhan, Bonatua Silalahi, and Tiurma M.S. Sihombing.
In their petition, the applicants request the Court to declare that the educational requirements stipulated in Article 169 letter r of the Election Law are imperative and must be legally fulfilled at the time of registration and the determination of presidential and vice-presidential pairs.
The petitioners are asking the Court to declare the disqualification of Vice President Gibrat Rakabuming Raka due to failure to meet the educational requirements as regulated in Article 169 letter r of the Election Law.
Furthermore, the petitioners request the Court to declare that the designation of Gibran Rakabuming Raka as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 Election was legally flawed from the outset and therefore has no binding legal force; and to nullify the KPU’s decision regarding the designation of Gibran Rakabuming Raka as Vice President.
Additionally, the petitioners seek the Court to annul the inauguration of Gibran Rakabuming Raka as Vice President conducted by the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR).
Finally, the petitioners request the Court to order the MPR to hold a session to elect a Vice President from two candidates proposed by the President no later than 60 days after this decision is read.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-dennys-lawsuit-is-a-momentum-for-the-constitutional-court-to-resolve-constitutional-issues-1790787262)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260930220630-12-1410227/pakar-gugatan-denny-cs-momentum-mk-tuntaskan-persoalan-konstitusi), translated from Indonesian