Expert: Constitutional Court Ruling on Gibran's Diploma Could Have Major Political Impact
The Constitutional Court (MK) has declined to accept a lawsuit regarding the validity of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s candidacy requirements for the 2024 Presidential Election.
The Court stated that Denny Indrayana and others, acting as petitioners in this case, lacked the necessary legal standing.
However, what has drawn significant attention is the Court’s observation that it found no documents proving that Gibran possesses a diploma equivalent to a Senior High School degree from his studies abroad.
Yoppy Adhi Hernawan, a researcher at the Centre for State Policy Studies (PSKN) and a Constitutional Law lecturer at Padjadjaran University’s Faculty of Law, highlighted the Court’s method in examining this case.
He noted that while the Court ruled the petitioners lacked legal standing, it nonetheless proceeded to state that it had not obtained convincing evidence in the form of certificates or diplomas that serve as the basis for educational equivalence.
“My note lies in how the Court reached that verdict, because the Court ventured quite deep into the substance of the case before returning to assess the petitioners’ legal standing,” Yuppy said via a short message on Wednesday.
Based on this, Yoppy believes that in this particular case, the Constitutional Court adopted a different pattern.
He mentioned that in general judicial practice, legal standing is typically the initial issue addressed.
“If someone is indeed not entitled to file a case, generally, the court does not need to examine the merits of the matter too deeply,” he said.
Yoppy further stated that the Court’s examination method could have a massive political impact, even though the petition was not accepted.
While the Constitutional Court did not disqualify Gibran, the Court did make findings regarding the proof of his educational requirements.
“Such considerations can certainly be reused by political actors outside the courtroom,” he remarked.
Yoppy then touched upon the concept of the ‘judicialisation of politics’ within constitutional law theory.
This theory essentially describes a situation where highly political issues, which were previously debated and resolved through political institutions, are increasingly brought to court to obtain legal resolution or legitimacy.
He noted that while this concept can serve a good purpose—as courts in a democracy must be able to monitor political processes based on the constitution—problems arise when judicial processes are used to gain an advantage in political competition.
“So, the issue I see is not just about Gibran. The larger precedent is whether, in the future, the processes at the Constitutional Court can be used by political actors to generate legal considerations against their political opponents, even if the party filing the case actually lacks legal standing,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-constitutional-court-ruling-on-gibrans-diploma-could-have-major-political-impact-1791417184)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261007190512-32-1412843/pakar-putusan-mk-soal-ijazah-gibran-buat-dampak-politik-besar), translated from Indonesian