Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert Claims Presidential Regulation on Tin Could Provide Basis for Harvey Moeis et al. to File Judicial Review

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Expert Claims Presidential Regulation on Tin Could Provide Basis for Harvey Moeis et al. to File Judicial Review
Image: CNN Indonesia

Legal expert Chairul Huda has highlighted Presidential Regulation (Perpres) Number 79 of 2026 concerning the Acceleration of Improved Governance of Tin Mining in the Bangka Belitung Islands Province.

Huda stated that this Presidential Regulation could serve as a basis for convicts in the tin trading corruption case to file for a judicial review (Peninjauan Kembali - PK). This includes businessmen such as Harvey Moeis and Alwin Albar, the former Operational Director of PT Timah for the 2015-2021 period, both of whom have received legally binding decisions regarding corruption in tin commodity trading within PT Timah’s territory.

“With this regulation, all PT Timah case decisions that have become legally binding can file for a judicial review based on this regulation,” Huda said, as quoted from a written statement on Tuesday (22/9).

According to him, the issuance of Perpres 79/2026 makes practices previously questioned in legal cases possess a basis of legality within tin mining governance. Huda believes there are legal consequences for cases that have already been decided and are legally binding (inkracht).

“Because with this regulation, what PT Timah and its private partners were doing effectively becomes legal,” he said.

Huda noted that this situation has the potential to create legal issues, as there is a discrepancy between the government’s previous treatment of certain practices and the policies issued currently. “If this is being legalised, then past actions must also be considered legal, even though there are already legally binding court decisions stating they were acts of corruption,” he added.

On that basis, Huda questioned the consistency of government policy regarding the practice of purchasing tin ore from the community within PT Timah’s concession areas. This is because the government, through the prosecutor’s office, had brought the tin trading governance case to court as a criminal corruption offence.

“So, the government itself considered this a violation of the law, and now the government also wants to validate it,” he remarked.

Furthermore, Huda questioned the form of the regulation issued by the government. He argued that a Presidential Regulation should regulate matters of national importance and actual national needs. Under this policy, PT Timah is permitted to purchase tin commodities produced by small-scale mining permit holders, taking into account quantity, quality, fair market prices, and small-scale mining levies.

Subsequently, the purchase of tin commodities must be agreed upon between the small-scale mining permit holders and PT Timah through a written agreement.

“The issue is the form of the Presidential Regulation. This regulation concerns tin mining governance specifically in the Bangka Belitung Islands Province. In my opinion, it is ‘too large a cloak’ for a regulation that is essentially local in nature,” he concluded.

More from 23 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-claims-presidential-regulation-on-tin-could-provide-basis-for-harvey-moeis-et-al-to-file-judicial-1790106699)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260922223829-12-1407044/pakar-sebut-perpres-timah-bisa-jadi-landasan-harvey-moeis-cs-ajukan-pk), translated from Indonesian
Print