Expert Claims Constitutional Court Ruling on Gibran's Diploma is a Serious Issue, Calls for KPU Investigation
Expert witness for the petitioners, Titi Anggrainani, believes that the Constitutional Court (MK) ruling regarding the educational requirements of Gibran Rakabuming Raka contains serious issues. According to Titi, the MK failed to find convincing evidence that Gibran possesses the diploma, certificate, or credentials that serve as the basis for equivalence with high school graduates or their equivalent.
“In my view, this ruling contains serious problems regarding the fulfilment of requirements for the vice-presidential candidacy. The MK did not find convincing evidence that Gibran possesses a diploma, certificate, or diploma that serves as the basis for high school graduation equivalence,” Titi told reporters on Wednesday (6/10/2026).
In this lawsuit, Titi served as the expert presented by the petitioners in the dispute over the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election results, which questioned Gibran’s educational requirements.
Titi noted that the MK also emphasised the distinction between possessing knowledge deemed equivalent to a vocational school (SMK) graduate and having actually completed that education. Titi assessed that Gibran’s educational requirements at the time of his vice-presidential candidacy were not met as stipulated by the Election Law.
“The MK also emphasised that having knowledge equivalent to an SMK graduate is different from actually completing that education,” she said. “However, in my assessment, Gibran’s educational requirements at the time of nomination were not met as required by the Election Law.”
Titi argued that the MK’s decision to declare the petition inadmissible should not be interpreted as a statement that Gibran’s educational requirements have been met. According to her, the petition was rejected because the petitioners lacked the legal standing to bring the case.
“That ruling does not mean the MK is stating that Gibrability’s educational requirements have been fulfilled,” said Titi.
Request for KPU Investigation
Titi subsequently highlighted the verification process of candidacy requirements conducted by the General Elections Commission (KPU). She suggested there are allegations of negligence in ensuring Gibran’s educational requirements were met.
“In my opinion, the KPU was negligent or perhaps even intentionally failed to ensure the meticulous fulfilment of those requirements,” she stated.
She believes the matter should be investigated through the mechanism of the Election Organ Ethics Council (DKPP), including allegations of ethical violations by KPU members responsible for the nomination process.
“Negligence or even unintentional error in verifying requirements for an office as high as Vice President is a very serious ethical issue,” she said.
Titi also requested that allegations of manipulating requirements through the adjustment of KPU Regulations (PKPU) be investigated. “The exclusion of graduation evidence in the PKPU must not be used to circumvent the educational requirements mandated by law,” she added.
Urging the DPR to Exercise Rights
Titi stated that the House of Representatives (DPR) could also use its authority in responding to the MK ruling regarding Gibran. She believes the DPR must take a stance.
“Therefore, I believe the DPR must now take responsibility to follow up on the MK’s findings through the use of its right to express an opinion,” she said.
Titi mentioned that this mechanism can be pursued based on Article 20A paragraph (2), within the framework of Articles 7A and 7B of the 1945 Constitution. The DPR, according to Titi, can draft an opinion based on evidence to be subsequently examined and decided upon by the MK.
If the MK upholds the DPR’s opinion, the process can proceed to the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) to make a final decision regarding dismissal.
“The MK’s material findings must not be left without accountability,” she asserted.
Titi noted that since providing her testimony as an expert at the MK, she had hoped the issue could be resolved directly by the MK through the submitted case. She did not wish for the process to be handed over to a political process.
“That is why when I provided expert testimony at the MK, I stated that this issue should be resolved directly by the MK and not left to a political process. Because if it becomes a political process, the follow-up becomes unmeasurable as it depends entirely on the good faith of the existing political forces,” she added.
Previously, the Constitutional Court (MK) did not accept the lawsuit regarding the educational requirements of Vice President Gibran Rakabulating Raka during his 2024 presidential registration. The MK stated that the petitioners lacked the legal standing to file the lawsuit.
The ruling session was held at the MK building in West Medan Merdeka, Central Jakarta, on Tuesday (6/10). The session was led by the Chief Justice of the MK, Suhartoyo.
“In the exception, we grant the petitioner’s exception regarding legal standing. We reject the respondent’s and related parties’ exceptions for the rest. Regarding the merits of the case, we declare the petitioners’ application inadmissible,” stated the MK.
The MK stated that the lawsuit was filed by parties who were not participants in the 2024 Presidential Election. However, in its considerations, the MK stated it found no evidence that Gibran possesses a high school equivalent diploma.
“The petitioners and related parties do not have legal standing,” said Suhartoyo.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-claims-constitutional-court-ruling-on-gibrans-diploma-is-a-serious-issue-calls-for-kpu-investigation-1791334519)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8695756/ahli-nilai-putusan-mk-soal-ijazah-gibran-masalah-serius-minta-kpu-diperiksa), translated from Indonesian