Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert: Cigarettes Cause Cancer, but Primarily Not Due to Nicotine

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Expert: Cigarettes Cause Cancer, but Primarily Not Due to Nicotine
Image: Media Indonesia

Cigarettes are proven to increase the risk of cancer. This danger is primarily related to various harmful compounds formed during the tobacco combustion process. Meanwhile, nicotine is better known as the compound that causes addiction and is not classified as a carcinogen.

Mohammad Khotib, a researcher from the Department of Chemistry at IPB University, explained that nicotine is a natural alkaloid compound found in tobacco and several plants from the Solanaceae family. This compound can affect the central nervous system and trigger the release of dopamine, creating a sense of pleasure that encourages dependency.

According to Khotib, the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) does not classify nicotine as a carcinogenic substance. The risk of cancer from smoking is more closely related to exposure to various harmful compounds produced when tobacco is burnt.

The combustion process of cigarettes can reach temperatures of approximately 900 degrees Celsius, producing more than 7,000 chemical compounds. Of these, around 70 are known to be carcinogenic and capable of damaging DNA and body tissues. These harmful compounds include tobacco-specific nitrosamines (TSNAs), benzene, 1,3-butadiene, benzo[a]pyrene, formaldehyde, tar, and carbon monoxide.

“Nicotine can cause addiction because it triggers the release of dopamine in the brain’s reward system, creating a sense of pleasure and encouraging a person to continue smoking. This is what makes the habit difficult to quit. However, the mechanism of addiction caused by nicotine is different from the process of cell damage or mutation that can trigger cancer,” said Khotib.

Although not classified as a carcinogen, Khotib emphasised that nicotine still poses health risks. The compound can cause addiction, increase heart rate and blood pressure, and potentially affect brain development in adolescents and foetuses. Therefore, products containing nicotine are not intended for children, adolescents, or vulnerable groups.

Khotib believes that understanding the difference between nicotine and combustion by-products is essential so that the public can obtain more accurate information regarding the risks of using tobacco products. “Proper understanding helps the public distinguish between addiction triggered by nicotine, and tissue damage and cancer triggered by exposure to toxic compounds and carcinogens resulting from tobacco combustion,” he explained.

On the other hand, the characteristics and risk profiles of various nicotine-based products need to be continuously assessed through scientific research. The Chairman of the Indonesia Free from TAR Coalition (KABAR), Ariyo Bimmo, stated that every product must be assessed based on its individual characteristics and scientific evidence.

According to Ariyo, differences between products can be seen in factors such as the presence or absence of a combustion process, the type of emissions or aerosols produced, product content, consumption patterns, and the potential for exposure to others. “Alternative tobacco products have different characteristics from cigarettes, so equating them is disproportionate. The differences to be observed include whether there is a combustion process, for example. Then the type of emissions or aerosols produced, product content, consumption patterns, and potential exposure to others. All of this is based on science,” he said.

Ariyo believes that more data and scientific studies can help provide a more comprehensive picture of the characteristics, exposure profiles, and risks of each product. “Policy must be based on data, scientific studies, and periodic evaluation,” he concluded.

The Ministry of Agriculture (Kementan) has reminded that the discourse on limiting nicotine and tar levels in tobacco products in Indonesia is not merely a regulatory matter.

However, British tobacco harm reduction expert Clive Bates noted that nicotine also has similar stimulant effects because it also affects dopamine release in the brain. The ability to remember, maintain concentration, and process information are vital parts of human cognitive function.

The Ministry of Health (Kemenkes) has warned that the dangers of vaping are equivalent to conventional cigarettes, stating that the content of 1 ml of vape liquid is said to be equivalent to 20 cigarettes.

Prof. Agus Dwi Susanto warned of the dangers of vaping among adolescents, which triggers nicotine addiction and the risk of lung damage and transitioning to conventional cigarettes.

More from 31 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-cigarettes-cause-cancer-but-primarily-not-due-to-nicotine-1788170015)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/kesehatan/927899/ahli-rokok-memang-penyebab-kanker-tapi-utamanya-bukan-dari-unsur-nikotin), translated from Indonesian
Print