Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Expert: Alleged Illegal Wiretapping of Head of State Must Be Investigated

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Expert: Alleged Illegal Wiretapping of Head of State Must Be Investigated
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — Alleged illegal wiretapping of the President could not only violate privacy and communications rights, but also constitute an abuse of authority or a serious criminal offence if it is proven to have been carried out outside legal procedures.

Oce Madril, executive director of the Association for the Study of Government Law and Anti-Corruption (Pushan), said wiretapping restricts citizens’ privacy rights. It must therefore have a legal basis and comply with applicable procedures.

He cited Article 32 of Law No. 39/1999 on Human Rights, which guarantees the freedom and confidentiality of correspondence, including communications via electronic means, except under an order from a judge or another lawful authority in accordance with legislation.

“Illegal wiretapping by a former National Police chief and several generals, allegedly targeting many people and even the President of the Republic of Indonesia, falls into the category of treason, abuse of authority and human rights violations,” Oce said.

The law academic at Gadjah Mada University (UGM) explained that alleged wiretapping without a legal basis, or unlawful interception, threatens not only state officials but also citizens’ rights. Privacy and communications are human rights that must be protected, he said.

Oce said wiretapping is, in principle, a special mechanism for law enforcement. It can be used to uncover serious and difficult-to-investigate crimes, such as corruption, bribery, terrorism and narcotics offences, provided it is conducted in accordance with the law.

However, wiretapping outside lawful procedures can itself amount to a legal violation. Oce also said it could be considered treason if it were proven to have been carried out with the aim of preventing the President from governing or unlawfully overthrowing the government.

“Such illegal action may be intended to prevent the President from carrying out the government’s work or to overthrow the President by unlawful means,” Oce explained.

He referred to provisions in the Criminal Code concerning offences against non-public electronic information transmissions. Article 258 of the Criminal Code sets out criminal penalties for anyone who unlawfully listens to, records, diverts, alters, obstructs or documents a non-public transmission of electronic information or an electronic document.

Oce said law-enforcement authorities needed to uncover the motive behind the alleged wiretapping, including who may have ordered it and who benefited from it.

“At this point, law enforcement needs to establish the motive behind the illegal wiretapping of the President and others. If it was indeed politically motivated, it is necessary to investigate who ordered it and who benefited politically from the illegal surveillance,” he added.

Beyond law enforcement, Oce highlighted the absence of comprehensive wiretapping rules in a single dedicated law. Provisions on surveillance are still scattered across various laws and regulations, each with a different approach, he said.

This situation could create problems in ensuring human rights protections, particularly the right to privacy. More detailed rules are therefore needed to guide wiretapping and prevent the abuse of authority.

“This is what raises concern about human rights guarantees. The lack of detailed regulation on wiretapping risks violating human rights and is inconsistent with constitutional principles,” he explained.

According to Oce, wiretapping regulations need to accommodate two interests: protecting human rights, especially privacy, and meeting law-enforcement needs. Surveillance can be a tool for uncovering certain crimes in the public interest, but its use must be constrained by clear legal mechanisms.

He therefore urged the creation of more comprehensive wiretapping rules to prevent the abuse of these powers and ensure they remain consistent with the principles of human rights protection.

More from 10 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/expert-alleged-illegal-wiretapping-of-head-of-state-must-be-investigated-1794311469)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/to9uxk522/pakar-dugaan-penyadapan-ilegal-terhadap-kepala-negara-perlu-diusut), translated from Indonesian
Print