Examining the Minister's Proposal to Relocate Women's Carriages on the KRL
The collision between the long-distance train (KAJJ) Argo Bromo Anggrek and a KRL at Bekasi Timur Station has left society in mourning. The government is committed to taking several measures to prevent similar incidents from recurring.
Various responses have emerged from the government, ranging from proposals for carriage rearrangements to evaluations of the rail transport safety system.
Proposal to Move Women’s Carriage to the Middle
Minister for Women’s Empowerment and Child Protection (PPPA) Arifah Fauzi has come under the spotlight after proposing that the women’s-only carriage on the KRL be moved to the middle of the train set. The proposal was made in the wake of the deadly accident at Bekasi Timur.
As is known, 15 people were recorded as having died as a result of the accident between the KA Argo Bromo Anggrek and the KRL at Bekasi Timur Station. The identified bodies are at several hospitals in the Bekasi and Jakarta areas.
“But with this incident, we propose that if possible, the women’s carriage be placed in the middle,” said Arifah to reporters after visiting victims at Bekasi City Hospital on Tuesday (28/4/2026).
Arifah claimed to have coordinated with KAI regarding the position of the women’s-only carriage, which has so far been at the front and rear of the train set.
“Earlier, when we talked with KAI, why it was placed at the very front and very back, so that there wouldn’t be any fighting,” she said.
However, according to Arifah, changes are needed following the accident. She proposed that the carriages at the ends be filled with male passengers.
“So the men at the ends. Front and back for men, so the women in the middle like that,” she said.
AHY: Focus on Safety, Not Gender
Coordinating Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development Agus Harimurti Yudhoyono responded to the proposal. He stressed that neither men nor women should become victims in any incident.
“Indeed, this has never happened before, a collision from the rear of the KRL hit by a long-distance train. And coincidentally, the rearmost one was the women’s-only carriage. There must be concern about why the most vulnerable group that we have specially prepared carriages for so far ends up facing the highest risk,” said AHY to reporters after visiting victims at Bekasi City Hospital on Tuesday (28/4/2026).
“This is also something we will continue to evaluate, but clearly, men and women are the same; no one should become a victim in any incident,” he added.
AHY emphasised that the main issue is not gender differences, but rather improving the transport safety system.
“So what we focus on is not women and men, but how the rail transport system and other public transport systems are safe, secure, provide a sense of safety, comfort, and safety first is truly not just a slogan but can be properly implemented,” he said.
He also assured that the National Transport Safety Committee (KNKT) will conduct a comprehensive and transparent investigation.
“KNKT has agreed to conduct a thorough investigation. I request it be transparent, open, and explained to the public. Because this also needs to be educational,” he said.
Chronology of the Consecutive Accidents
The accident began when a Green SM taxi stopped in the middle of the railway tracks not far from Bekasi Timur Station on Monday (27/4) night. The taxi was then hit by a KRL travelling from Cikarang to Jakarta.
The KRL involved in the incident then stopped in the middle of the tracks. Residents gathered to help with the evacuation of the taxi.
On the other hand, there was a KRL heading to Cikarang that was held longer at Bekasi Timur Station due to the previous incident. The KRL stopped at the station was then hit by the KA Argo Bromo Anggrek travelling from Jakarta.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/examining-the-ministers-proposal-to-relocate-womens-carriages-on-the-krl-1777434753)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/berita/d-8466342/menilik-usulan-menteri-ubah-posisi-gerbong-wanita-di-krl), translated from Indonesian