Evidence That Indonesia Is Lagging Far Behind Vietnam
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – Senior economist and CReco Research Institute founder Raden Pardede says manufacturing accounts for a limited share of Indonesia’s exports compared with Vietnam’s.
For example, of exports worth US$300 billion, manufacturing accounts for only half. In Vietnam, manufacturing makes up 80% of exports, which are close to US$550 billion.
Raden did not specify the period covered by his figures. According to Statistics Indonesia (BPS), Indonesia’s exports totalled US$221.23 billion in January-September 2026, with the manufacturing industry accounting for 82.64% of the total.
Meanwhile, citing the Vietnamese government’s official website, exports are estimated to have reached US$499 billion in January-October 2026. Manufactured and processed industrial products continued to play a leading role, accounting for 87.4% of total exports.
“Manufacturing accounts for only half of that US$300 billion for us. For them, it is more than 80%. That works out to about US$150 billion in manufacturing exports for us, while theirs are nearly 80%,” Raden said on the Cuap Cuap Cuan programme, as quoted on Wednesday (11 November 2026).
Raden stressed that Vietnam’s manufacturing industry provides significant employment despite the country having a smaller population than Indonesia. Indonesia has nearly 300 million people, compared with Vietnam’s 100 million. Assuming Vietnam’s manufacturing exports reach US$450 billion, the figure is far above Indonesia’s US$150 billion.
“We are only a third of theirs, yet our population is three times larger. We have long said that manufacturing is a sector that creates decent jobs. That is where the difference lies,” he said.
Raden also said the impact of investment realised in Indonesia should be examined more closely, particularly its contribution to job creation. Even where jobs are created, he questioned whether they are decent and help raise people’s incomes.
The Ministry of Investment and Downstreaming/Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) announced that realised investment in Indonesia reached Rp528.7 trillion in the third quarter of 2026.
The figure rose 7.6% year on year. Investment realisation in the third quarter of 2026 was higher than the Rp498.79 trillion recorded in the first quarter and Rp511.8 trillion in the second quarter.
Indonesia recorded 745,634 jobs created in the third quarter of 2026, alongside investment realisation of Rp528.7 trillion. Employment rose 7.06% year on year from 696,478 in the same period last year.
In total, 2.19 million jobs were recorded in January-September 2026, alongside investment realisation of Rp1,539.2 trillion. However, the government has not provided a full breakdown of the subsectors or investment projects that generated the most employment.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/evidence-that-indonesia-is-lagging-far-behind-vietnam-1794372693)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261111104046-4-784164/bukti-indonesia-tertinggal-jauh-dari-vietnam), translated from Indonesian