Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Everyone Talks Sharia, But Who Will Resolve the Legal Bottlenecks?

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Regulation
Everyone Talks Sharia, But Who Will Resolve the Legal Bottlenecks?
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Our public space has been almost incessantly filled in recent months with discussions about the Sharia economy. Forums are held, resolutions are announced, and optimism is spread. There are public discussions on the “Sharia Economy Resolution 2026”, television forums on strengthening the ecosystem, and various statements that the Sharia economy must become one of the pillars of national transformation. It all sounds promising.

The problem is, amid the increasing buzz of Sharia economy discussions, one disturbing irony emerges: the discourse is very lively, yet the legal bottlenecks remain untouched. Many are enthusiastic about talking about opportunities, while only a few are willing to enter the quieter and heavier space: legislative politics, norm synchronisation, and structuring the legal framework that will greatly influence the direction and speed of the Sharia economy’s progress.

At this point, we need to be honest with ourselves. Indonesia does not lack forums, slogans, or optimistic jargon. What is lacking is firm legal political decisions. Who is really willing to resolve the Sharia economy’s legal bottlenecks? Who is ready to push it from seminar rooms to the legislative table?

This question is important because Indonesia’s Sharia economy is not standing still. OJK data shows that the Sharia financial services industry continues to grow positively, while Sharia banking also records financing growth throughout 2025.

From the real economy side, the halal value chain is even said to have made a significant contribution to national GDP, and Indonesia remains in a strategic position on the global Sharia economy map. This means our potential is not illusory. The engine is running. The market exists. The enthusiasm is real.

But precisely because of that, the legal question becomes increasingly urgent. Why, when the industry is already running, is our legislative politics still limping along? Why, when everyone talks about a Sharia economic leap, is the Sharia Economy Bill left in hibernation?

This is the real core of the bottleneck. So far, the Sharia economy has been built with a sectoral approach. There are Sharia banking regulations, Sharia capital market rules, halal regulations, zakat, waqf, and various derivative policies. All important, but they operate like isolated regulatory islands. There is movement, but the orchestration is not yet complete. There is growth, but the integrative foundation is unfinished.

In such conditions, the Sharia economy grows with great energy but limited legal coordination. Each subsector moves with its own sectoral logic.

Yet Sharia banks cannot be separated from the halal industry, SMEs, Sharia social institutions, guarantee institutions, fiscal policies, and even dispute resolution systems. If the framework remains scattered, we are asking an ecosystem to work with legal tools that were never designed as an ecosystem.

Therefore, the need for the Sharia Economy Bill as an umbrella act is no longer just about adding a new law. It is about structuring the architecture. It is about compiling a national legal compass so that the Sharia economy does not continue to grow partially, but moves within a grand development design.

However, it must be honestly acknowledged that the biggest challenge is not in academic arguments. Arguments about the urgency of umbrella legislation have been repeatedly presented. The real challenge is legislative politics. It is at this level that the Sharia economy’s energy often evaporates.

What is meant by “legislative politics” here is actually simple: how the DPR and the government choose which bills to prioritise for discussion and enactment. In the case of the Sharia Economy Bill, the issue is not that the idea is not ready, but that it must share space with many other bills on the discussion table.

On the other hand, the harmonisation process with existing regulations is still ongoing, while truly consolidated political support has not yet formed, so this bill repeatedly fails to rise to the annual priority list. Everyone agrees in forums, everyone is enthusiastic in seminars, but when it comes to determining legislative priorities, what emerges is a long silence.

This silence is not without consequences. Legal bottlenecks do not just delay system tidiness, but also suppress on-the-ground practice boldness. The impact is most clearly seen in Sharia banking. In this sector, the uncertainty between legitimate business risks and potential criminalisation when financing goes problematic remains strong.

As a result, decision-makers often proceed with the handbrake on: tasked with supporting the real sector, SMEs, pesantren economy, and productive small businesses, but at the same time continually worrying that business risks might be perceived as deviations leading to criminal penalties.

This example shows that legal bottlenecks are not merely abstract issues in academic spaces, but directly influence institutional behaviour. The Sharia Economy Bill is not intended to regulate the technical separation of business risks from crimes, but as an umbrella that structures the legal architecture and regulatory coordination.

Without an integrative umbrella and clear direction at the design level, efforts to tidy up derivative regulations, including those touching the boundary between business risks and criminal acts, will only move partially and scattered. In such a situation, the boldness to make decisions is almost always smaller than the enthusiasm for speeches about economic justice.

Therefore, our agenda going forward must be firmer. Public discourse on the Sharia economy must level up from mere idea spaces to legal political consolidation.

More from 30 April 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/everyone-talks-sharia-but-who-will-resolve-the-legal-bottlenecks-1777546510)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260430151623-14-731340/semua-bicara-syariah-tapi-siapa-yang-selesaikan-bottleneck-hukumnya), translated from Indonesian
Print