Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

ESG Alone Is Not Enough: Why Investors Need to Perform 'Triple Checks'

| | Source: unair.ac.id Translated from Indonesian | Finance
ESG Alone Is Not Enough: Why Investors Need to Perform 'Triple Checks'
Image: unair.ac.id

In recent years, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) has become one of the primary indicators in investment decision-making. Companies with high ESG scores are often perceived as more responsible, more sustainable, and as carrying lower long-term risk. But does an ESG reputation truly reflect the overall quality of a company? Recent research entitled From Triple Bottom Line to Triple Checks: The Interplay Between ESG, Conservatism, and Investor Trust shows that the answer is not always yes. The study analysed 13,398 firm observations from 30 countries over the period 2010–2022. It was conducted by Suham Cahyono (Doctoral Candidate in Accounting Science at Universitas Airlangga), Prof. Dr. Ardianto, SE., M.Si., Ak., CA. (Professor of Behavioural Accounting and Performance at Universitas Airlangga), and Prof. Dr. Hadrian Geri Djajadikerta (Professor at the School of Accounting, Finance, and Economics, Curtin University, Australia). The results reveal a fairly surprising finding: the higher a company’s level of ESG disclosure, the lower its level of accounting conservatism. In other words, companies that are very active in building a sustainability narrative do not necessarily apply the same principle of prudence in their financial reporting. Why does this matter?

Accounting conservatism is a principle that encourages companies to be more cautious in recognising profits and to recognise potential losses more quickly. This principle has long been regarded as a mechanism for protecting investors from overly optimistic financial reports. When conservatism weakens, there is a risk that financial information becomes less reliable, even if the company has a good ESG image. These findings do not mean that ESG is a bad concept. On the contrary, ESG remains important as an indicator of a company’s responsibility towards the environment, society, and governance. However, the research reminds us that ESG can become merely symbolic if it is not accompanied by adequate quality of financial reporting. Under certain conditions, an ESG reputation can even create excessive confidence, causing investors to become less critical of the quality of a company’s financial reports. This is the phenomenon often associated with greenwashing, whereby a company builds a strong sustainability image through various disclosures, but its business practices and the quality of its information do not fully reflect that commitment. The study finds that this condition is more likely to occur in companies with high legitimacy in the public eye, particularly in developed countries and companies with strong governance, because their reputations tend to be more readily trusted by the market.

Based on these findings, the authors propose a new approach called Triple Checks. This approach invites investors not only to evaluate ESG scores, but also to examine two other aspects: the quality of accounting conservatism and the level of investor trust in company information. These three aspects need to be assessed together in order to distinguish companies that are genuinely sustainable from those that merely build a sustainability image. For regulators, the results of this research carry the message that ESG reporting standards should not focus solely on the volume of information disclosed, but should also ensure that such information is supported by quality financial reporting and effective oversight mechanisms. Meanwhile, for investors, an ESG score should be the beginning of an analysis, not the end of the decision-making process. Ultimately, a company’s sustainability cannot be measured solely by how well it talks about ESG. True sustainability must be reflected in consistency between the narrative, the financial figures, and disciplined governance. In the era of sustainable investment, market trust cannot be built on image alone, but must be reinforced by verifiable evidence. That is the essence of the Triple Checks approach.

The details of this paper can be found at: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/bsd2.70323

More from 22 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/esg-alone-is-not-enough-why-investors-need-to-perform-triple-checks-1784710235)
Originally published by unair.ac.id (https://unair.ac.id/esg-saja-tidak-cukup-mengapa-investor-perlu-melakukan-triple-checks/), translated from Indonesian
Print