Environment Minister: Legal Penalties Are Not Enough; Damaged Ecosystems Must Be Restored
DENPASAR — Environment Minister and Head of the Environmental Control Agency (BPLH) Mohammad Jumhur Hidayat stressed that environmental law enforcement must not stop at imposing sanctions on offenders. The government must also ensure that damaged ecosystems are restored and affected communities are protected.
“Nature cannot testify in a courtroom. Rivers cannot file complaints, forests cannot bring lawsuits and coral reefs cannot take an oath. Experts are their voice. Law without science will be blind, and science without law will be paralysed,” Jumhur said as he opened the 2026 Environmental Experts Forum in Bali on Tuesday (20 October 2026).
The forum, which runs until 22 October, brings together practitioners, academics and law enforcement officials to strengthen environmental enforcement focused on restoration. Under the theme “Strengthening Restoration-Oriented Environmental Law Enforcement to Achieve Climate Justice through Optimising the Role of Experts”, the event emphasises the importance of scientific evidence in establishing accountability for environmental damage.
Jumhur said experts play an important role in providing objective data and analysis to bridge scientific knowledge and judicial proceedings. Scientific evidence is needed to establish the facts of environmental damage and to serve as a basis for determining both accountability and the form of restoration required.
As one step towards restoration-oriented law enforcement, the government filed a lawsuit in early 2026 against six companies over alleged environmental damage covering more than 2,500 hectares in North Sumatra. The claim is worth more than Rp4.8 trillion.
The Ministry of Environment/Environmental Control Agency (KLH/BPLH) said it respects the ongoing judicial process. The government hopes the enforcement action will lead to the restoration of ecosystems and the living spaces of affected communities.
Supreme Court Civil Chamber Chief Prof Hamdi stressed that the resolution of environmental cases must take long-term impacts into account. In his view, law enforcement is not enough if it merely identifies violations and imposes sanctions.
“The theme we have chosen today carries a fundamental message. Environmental law enforcement cannot stop at identifying violations and imposing sanctions. We must also ensure that damaged environments are restored, affected communities are protected, and similar damage is prevented from recurring year after year,” Hamdi said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/environment-minister-legal-penalties-are-not-enough-damaged-ecosystems-must-be-restored-1792576322)
Originally published by Republika (https://esgnow.republika.co.id/berita/tn93oa370/menteri-lh-sanksi-hukum-tak-cukup-ekosistem-rusak-harus-dipulihkan), translated from Indonesian