Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Ensuring Social Protection Reaches the Right Targets

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Ensuring Social Protection Reaches the Right Targets
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Effective social protection is not about how sophisticated the government’s data reading capabilities are. The true measure is much simpler: whether the state is able to find those who truly need help, avoid misjudging those whose circumstances have improved, and provide a way out for the vulnerable.

There is an irony within our social protection system. Citizens who are visibly in need of assistance can be excluded simply because of a figure on a piece of paper. Conversely, those who administratively meet the criteria remain recorded as recipients, even though their standard of living has improved.

The city of Surabaya, East Java, is currently facing this very issue. The Digital Social Protection Programme has reached 1,004,298 households. At the same time, the update process has found that 219,000 residents could not be located, and approximately 26,000 residents are recorded as deceased.

These figures demonstrate that the greatest task in social protection is not merely building digital systems, but ensuring that those systems recognise actual human beings. According to the Central Bureau of Statistics (BPS), the number of poor residents in Surabaya as of March 20lar 2025 was 105.09 thousand people, or 3.56 per cent of the population. While this figure is decreasing compared to the previous year, poverty is never static.

Some families move up the economic ladder, some fall back into poverty, and there are vulnerable groups living just above the poverty line who can easily slip back below it. Therefore, the social protection database should not be read merely as a list of the poor. It is a map of who requires state protection, who is currently vulnerable, and who has managed to escape dependency on aid.

In this context, the issue of vehicle ownership serves as an important lesson. Officers found residents whose housing and socio-economic conditions indicated a need for assistance, yet the system recorded them as car owners. Upon further investigation, it was discovered that the vehicle was linked to their employment as a driver, with the vehicle registration (STNK) being recorded under their name.

In other cases, residents’ identity cards (KTP) were reportedly borrowed to register vehicle ownership. Such issues reveal a fundamental weakness when administrative data is treated as a perfect mirror of social conditions. While a National Identity Number (NIK) confirms an individual’s identity and an STNK shows the registered owner, neither necessarily explains who actually enjoys the asset, who bears the cost of living, or the true economic capacity of a family.

More from 6 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ensuring-social-protection-reaches-the-right-targets-1791251800)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5772744/agar-perlindungan-tak-salah-alamat), translated from Indonesian
Print