Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Ensure the Asset Forfeiture Bill Does Not Create Fear Among Businesses

| | Source: monitorindonesia.com Translated from Indonesian | Investment
Ensure the Asset Forfeiture Bill Does Not Create Fear Among Businesses
Image: monitorindonesia.com

The Draft Law on Asset Forfeiture is one of the legal instruments expected to strengthen efforts to combat economic crime in Indonesia. It is important to ensure that criminals cannot continue to enjoy the proceeds of crime, while also giving the state a more effective means of recovering losses caused by such offences.

However, a fundamental issue must not be overlooked in drafting the regulation: how to ensure that asset-forfeiture powers do not create legal uncertainty that harms the public and the business community.

From a public policy perspective, the success of a regulation cannot be measured solely by the breadth of the powers it grants the state. It must also be judged by its ability to deliver justice, maintain public trust and provide certainty for economic activity.

This is why the Asset Forfeiture Bill must be considered with particular care. Arbitrary asset seizures could not only violate citizens’ rights but also undermine investors’ confidence in Indonesia’s legal system.

Legal certainty as the foundation of investment

Investment is fundamentally built on trust. When an individual or company invests capital, they consider not only the potential returns but also the legal risks and policy stability of the country in which they are investing.

Investors need assurance that assets acquired through legitimate business activities will be protected by law. They must also be confident that any state action affecting ownership of assets will follow transparent, objective procedures that can be challenged in court.

If the state has overly broad powers to freeze, seize or forfeit assets without clear limits, the risk of legal uncertainty will increase.

The issue is not simply whether an investor has committed a crime. In business practice, company assets may be connected to complex legal arrangements, including share ownership, bank financing, credit security and partnerships with third parties.

When an asset is seized, the consequences may extend to parties with no involvement in the alleged crime.

For example, freezing company assets without a proportionate assessment could disrupt business operations, payments to suppliers, obligations to creditors and the livelihoods of employees.

If such action is later found to lack an adequate legal basis, the resulting economic and reputational damage may not be fully reversible.

The Asset Forfeiture Bill must therefore draw a clear distinction between assets genuinely connected to criminal activity and those obtained through legitimate economic activity.

Do not let crime-fighting become a new risk for business

Indonesia needs investment to drive economic growth, create jobs and strengthen national competitiveness. In this context, consistent policies and legal certainty are crucial.

The state must, of course, take a firm stance against corruption, money laundering and other economic crimes. But strong law enforcement must not be equated with granting powers without adequate oversight mechanisms.

There is a fundamental difference between robust law enforcement and enforcement without effective restraints.

Robust enforcement is based on evidence, fair procedures and judicial oversight. By contrast, unchecked enforcement risks opening the door to abuse of power, discriminatory treatment and even interference in legitimate economic activity.

In the investment context, even the perception that powers might be abused can influence business decisions.

Investors may delay expansion, increase their risk assessments or move their capital to countries they consider to have more predictable legal protections.

This means that, if designed carelessly, an instrument intended to recover state losses could instead cause new economic harm.

Lessons from international experience

Experience in various countries shows that asset-forfeiture laws do not automatically guarantee the successful recovery of the proceeds of crime.

The challenges often lie instead in law-enforcement agencies’ capacity, the quality of judicial oversight, the transparency of asset management and the state’s ability to prevent abuses of power.

Regulations that confer extensive powers without strengthening institutions risk creating new problems.

This is particularly important when asset forfeiture is carried out without a prior criminal conviction, a mechanism known as non-conviction-based asset forfeiture (NCB).

Such a mechanism can be useful in certain circumstances, for example when an offender has fled or criminal proceedings cannot continue for reasons recognised by law. However, its application requires clear standards of proof and independent judicial oversight.

Without such safeguards, there is a risk that asset-forfeiture powers could be used disproportionately, including for purposes unrelated to combating crime.

International experience should remind Indonesia that adopting a legal instrument considered modern is not enough. The country must also ensure that the institutions responsible for implementing it are ready.

Protecting businesses and third parties

One aspect of the Asset Forfeiture Bill requiring serious attention is protection for good-faith third parties.

In a modern economy, an asset does not always stand alone or belong to a single party. It may form part of a financing structure, an investment partnership or a commercial transaction involving multiple parties.

For that reason, asset seizure or forfeiture must take account of the rights of others who have lawfully acquired a legal interest in the asset.

The regulation should provide an effective mechanism for objections, an opportunity to prove the origin of ownership and procedures for judicial review.

It should also establish the principle of proportionality, so that freezing or seizure does not go beyond what is necessary for law enforcement.

The state must not ignore the wider economic impact of action against productive assets.

Such protections do not amount to defending criminals. On the contrary, strong legal safeguards will enhance the state’s legitimacy in tackling economic crime.

Discussion of the Asset Forfeiture Bill should not be reduced to a debate between those who support and those who oppose the fight against corruption.

Everyone wants the proceeds of crime returned to the state. The more substantive question is how to achieve that goal without creating powers that could be abused.

From a public policy perspective, several principles should guide the drafting of this regulation.

First, the limits of law-enforcement agencies’ powers must be clearly defined, including the conditions for freezing, seizing and forfeiting assets.

Second, every action must be supported by evidence that can be tested through independent judicial proceedings.

Third, the protection of legitimate property rights and good-faith third parties must be guaranteed in practice, rather than merely stated as a general principle.

Fourth, seized assets must be managed transparently and accountably to prevent new opportunities for misconduct.

Fifth, deliberations on the regulation must take account of its effects on the investment climate, business activity and national economic stability.

These principles are essential to ensure that asset forfeiture serves as an instrument of justice, rather than a source of legal uncertainty.

Ultimately, a strong state is not one with the broadest powers to take its citizens’ assets, but one that can enforce the law firmly while respecting constitutional rights.

Indonesia needs an effective Asset Forfeiture Bill to combat economic crime. But that effectiveness must go hand in hand with legal certainty and protection for legitimate economic activity.

Efforts to recover state losses must not create uncertainty that causes businesses to lose confidence in investing. The proceeds of crime must indeed be forfeited, but investors’ confidence in the rule of law must be protected.

More from 18 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ensure-the-asset-forfeiture-bill-does-not-create-fear-among-businesses-1792335020)
Originally published by monitorindonesia.com (https://monitorindonesia.com/opini/read/2026/10/637029/jangan-sampai-ruu-perampasan-aset-menciptakan-ketakutan-di-kalangan-pelaku-usaha), translated from Indonesian
Print