Enough is enough for RI Chinese
Enough is enough for RI Chinese
By Rahayu Ratnaningsih
This is the second of two articles on the relationship between
people of Chinese and Malay descent in the country.
JAKARTA (JP): I would like to take myself as living proof of
how cruel sweeping generalizations can be. I was born in
Indonesia, speak no Chinese but Indonesian, Sundanese and
English, only have an Indonesian name, mingle mostly with and
feel at total ease around indigenous Indonesians and have never
lived in an exclusively Chinese housing complex.
I played with kampong kids as a child, sometimes ate from
their plates and slept in their beds. Most of my good friends are
Muslim pribumi. Today, I'm no longer even in touch with any of
the Chinese traditions; not even Chinese new year has any
significant meaning for me.
There were almost no exclusively Chinese neighborhoods where
we lived in a densely populated kampong in Bogor. Poor and modest
Chinese-Indonesians lived side by side with pribumi. My father
did not even graduate from high school because his parents were
so poor. Many of the hundreds of members of our extended family
flitted from one menial job to another in order to earn their
living.
We're nothing at all like how many pribumi generalize Chinese-
Indonesians to be; filthy-rich economic animals. When at
university, many of my pribumi friends drove to campus while many
of the Chinese students, including myself, who constituted a
small minority in accordance with the quota policy set for
Chinese at state universities, took public buses.
I would admit there are certainly greedy, fascist and corrupt
Chinese-Indonesian businesspeople that deify their wealth; the
type of people who feel comfortable being able to dictate
anything or to anyone they want with their money.
Of course, there are also Chinese-Indonesians who live in
mansions secluded by high fences. But aren't there indigenous
Indonesians who also fall into these categories? Do rich pribumi
who live in Menteng or Pondok Indah really mingle with their
neighbors, let alone with the kampong people in their
neighborhood?
Some people suggest that Chinese-Indonesians should not build
big, luxurious houses because it may create jealousy. Surely it
would be better to suggest that all rich people, of Chinese
origin or otherwise, refrain from doing so. But then again, does
this impulsive plea really touch the core of the problem?
Many pribumi fail to see that, just like themselves, Chinese-
Indonesians are also heterogeneous. They come in different forms
and with different baggage. Chinese-Indonesians from Tangerang,
who are indistinguishable from the pribumi, are totally different
from those in Medan. Similarly Chinese-Indonesians from Central
Java who speak Javanese in their daily lives are not the same as
Chinese-Indonesians from Pontianak.
Admittedly there are various degrees of assimilation between
Chinese-Indonesians and pribumi from one area to another; some
are more exclusive than others. But to generalize that all
Chinese are exclusive and racist is absurd as my own experience
at personal and professional levels testifies.
As a headhunter I have experienced situations in which a
Chinese-Indonesian businessman demanded an accountant of Chinese
ethnicity; similarly state companies weed out Chinese-Indonesians
from the ideal-employee candidate portfolio.
Nowadays many younger Chinese-Indonesians are professionals or
private sector employees, such as myself and many of my friends.
Others are intellectuals, athletes, artists, teachers or
professors.
The only problem is that we are so prone to double standards.
When a Chinese-Indonesian is arrested for being involved in a
scam, his Chinese identity is readily revealed by the media; but
when Kwik Kian Gie's, Onghokham's, or Arief Budiman's ideas and
thoughts are widely accepted or Susi Susanti's and Rudy Hartono's
international achievements applauded, they are regarded as
exceptions.
They are indeed exceptions, as are Abdurrahman Wahid,
Nurcholish Madjid and Romo Mangun. Remarkable people always
belong to minorities, regardless of their racial background.
However, it's totally unfair to generalize that the average
Chinese-Indonesian is rotten. The majority are in fact obedient
citizens who follow everything officials ask of them.
They dutifully change their names to Indonesian or even Arabic
ones, quietly celebrate Chinese new year, or even change their
traditional faith, Confucianism, to one of the five sanctioned
religions. They dutifully present a stack of documents ranging
from birth certificate, certificate of citizenship to certificate
of name change every time they have to obtain or renew essential
documents, or enroll their children in schools.
Imagine the bureaucracy; as long as you look Chinese you
always have to be able to prove that you are an Indonesian
citizen, despite the fact that you were born in Indonesia of
Indonesian parents, were educated in the country, speak only
Indonesian and only have an Indonesian name.
You continue to have to undergo this ordeal even when you
possess an ID card or Indonesian passport that has required you
to follow the same lengthy process to acquire it in the first
place.
People should understand that being politically impotent,
money is the only tool most Chinese-Indonesians can use to
bargain with. Many, such as my father, are dismayed and tormented
by this unjust discrimination and blackmail to the extent that
they no longer want to deal with the bureaucrats themselves but
through a third party.
This has created a fertile environment for "brokerage"
services which is unknown in countries with efficient public
services and minimal levels of corruption.
It is, therefore, simply ludicrous to blame the rampant
corruption and collusion that plagues Indonesia on the 4 percent
of the population that is of Chinese descent. It doesn't take
much intelligence to see how foolish the assertion is.
How many Chinese-Indonesians really have access to power? From
a population of about eight million, let's say 8,000 have regular
business connections with high-ranking officials which equates to
only 0.1 percent of the Chinese-Indonesian population.
So, where does the baseless assertion come from that most
Chinese are devious businessmen who have acquired their wealth
through collusion alone?
Do those people really know how it feels to be financially and
emotionally blackmailed at almost every bureaucratic hurdle when
dealing with pribumi officials? Is it unthinkable that given a
choice between progress or stagnation they will rely on their
money to lubricate the countless corrupt wheels in the system?
Perhaps they should ponder what would happen if Chinese-
Indonesians refused to dig deep into their pockets? Bribery is a
way of life here. Both Chinese and non-Chinese are forced to pay
to get things done, the difference is the Chinese pay more. They
have to. Who presides over public service and government offices?
Indigenous Indonesians.
Hence, once again, where does the hypocritical allegation that
Chinese-Indonesians are the culprits of the oppressive system
that has victimized Indonesian people come from?
In other words, racism, corruption and collusion cut both
ways; they are inseparable from the system. The system is to
blame. And exclusivity and individualism are typical traits of
urban societies, the members of which have little time to
socialize after a long day at work. So, I think the real issue is
not about Chinese versus pribumi but the gap between rich and
poor.
The issue is the failure of Soeharto's regime to create a just
system that gives equal opportunities to all citizens, both
pribumi and non-pribumi, in all sectors of life.
Had the Chinese been given access to noneconomic sectors they
would not have concentrated on only making money. Had they been
admitted into the government offices, their contributions to
society would have been more palpable to simple-minded, average
indigenous Indonesians who tend to associate any Chinese-
Indonesian contribution to the economy as a mere product of greed
and materialism.
These people are seemingly unaware that without the Chinese-
Indonesians' thriving businesses the whole country's economy
would crumble, a foretaste of which we are witnessing today.
An English friend grimly recalled recently how sad he was
knowing one of the computer shops he regularly frequented in
Glodok had been burned and looted. The Chinese owner was a
reliable young man who did his utmost to service his clients. He
gave honest advice and information on his products, reasonable
prices and excellent after sales service. He certainly did not
conform to the stereotype some indigenous Indonesians subscribe
to when they think of Chinese-Indonesian businesspeople: greedy,
cheeky and divisive.
I'm very sure 95 percent of Chinese businesspeople thrive
because they can provide consistently good and reliable services
at reasonable, competitive prices. They thrive because even
indigenous Indonesians themselves, as well as foreigners, benefit
from doing business with them. Deep down, probably without
realizing it, pribumi often prefer doing business with Chinese-
Indonesians more than with their own people.
This confidence was the very reason why the Indonesian
government, in the early stages of the country's development,
gave a lot of concessions to Chinese businesspeople. There is no
doubt that they are the engine of the country's economy. They
provide services that people need. On top of that, they provide
sources of livelihood to many pribumi so that when they are
looted and attacked the rioters have in fact not only bitten but
cut off the hands that feed their own people!
The fact that now they're too economically powerful, leaving a
rift between them and their indigenous counterparts, is not their
fault. It's the government, with its poor economic policies and
low-quality officials, which is to blame. Soeharto conveniently
forgot that there was an equally important task parallel to
economic development, namely nation building.
To summarize, the pervasive prejudice among native Indonesians
against the Chinese-Indonesian community constitutes another
large dent in Indonesia's already battered image. Previously our
government was perceived to be one of the world's worst human
rights violators, and now, following the riots, certain sections
of society have proved that they too are capable of the most
appalling atrocities.
Indonesia is in the spotlight, and as the dust from the
ransacked buildings settles, the world is left staring at the
stain of bigotry. It is a stain that seeps deep into the
consciousness of people the world over; from the potential
investors who may have found some remnants of hope in our ailing
business sector, to the holidaymakers for whom the news footage
of flames and bloodshed has been superimposed on their vision of
paradise islands.
The writer is a human resources consultant based in Jakarta.
Window: Previously our government was perceived to be one of the
world's worst human rights violators, and now, following the
riots, certain sections of society have proved that they too are
capable of the most appalling atrocities.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/enough-is-enough-for-ri-chinese-1447893297-1409645)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post