Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Enforcement Against Mining Mafia Must Be Transparent, Says Lawyer

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Mining
Enforcement Against Mining Mafia Must Be Transparent, Says Lawyer
Image: CNN Indonesia

Peradi Profesional Deputy Chairman Krisna Murti has called for law enforcement against mining-sector mafias to be carried out professionally, firmly and transparently.

He said President Prabowo Subianto’s move to bring order to the mining sector deserved support, as it was important both to reduce losses to state finances and to stamp out mining-mafia practices.

“We agree with President Prabowo’s statement that mining should be brought under control so these mafias do not continue to run rampant,” Krisna said in a written statement on Tuesday (13 October).

Krisna urged the government to strengthen the role of the Task Force for the Control of Forest Areas (Satgas PKH) so that law enforcement against mining-sector violations complies with the rules.

“The state established the Satgas PKH under a presidential regulation, so it must properly and correctly enforce the law, rather than being used as a bargaining tool by law enforcement officials,” he said.

Krisna also highlighted the application of the principle of strict liability in handling environmental crimes. Under this principle, responsibility for environmental damage may be imposed without proof of fault in cases that meet the relevant legal requirements.

However, he cautioned that the principle must be applied carefully, particularly when determining who is responsible for environmental damage in mining areas.

Problems could arise, he said, if legal responsibility were imposed on a new mining business permit (IUP) holder even though the alleged violation or damage occurred while the mine was operated by a previous permit holder.

“For example, if excavation had already taken place under the previous owner, the previous owner should be held responsible. That can be established in various ways; the new IUP holder’s liability should not be assumed when the start of its mining operations can be checked,” he said.

He said authorities could use several methods to establish when mining activities took place, including satellite-image analysis. Such evidence could help distinguish damage or mining carried out under a previous permit holder from activity by the new holder.

Responsibility should therefore be assigned on the basis of evidence and the period when the violation occurred, rather than solely on the basis of who currently holds the permit.

“It is unfair to make a new owner responsible for old, unauthorised excavation. Misapplication of the strict-liability principle can be used by officials to put pressure on the new rights holder,” he said.

Krisna also raised concerns about administrative penalties for mining, saying they must be calculated fairly.

For example, he said, penalties for nickel-related violations should not be calculated on a per-year basis, because nickel mining does not involve repeated harvests. Once the nickel has been extracted, it cannot quickly grow back.

This differs from oil-palm plantations, where production can be calculated annually because crops can be harvested repeatedly according to their growing cycle.

Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Decree No. 391.K/MB.01/MEM.B/2025 sets administrative fines at Rp6.5 billion per hectare for nickel, Rp1.76 billion for bauxite, Rp1.25 billion for tin and Rp354 million for coal.

Meanwhile, Government Regulation No. 45 of 2025 sets an administrative fine of Rp25 million per hectare for oil-palm plantations established in forest areas without forestry permits.

“Take nickel, for example: once it is mined, it does not grow back. It would take thousands of years for it to become fossilised again and be mined, so mining should not be calculated on a per-year basis,” Krisna said.

More from 13 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/enforcement-against-mining-mafia-must-be-transparent-says-lawyer-1791913897)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261013222953-12-1415001/berantas-mafia-tambang-penegakan-hukum-diminta-transparan), translated from Indonesian
Print