Energy-Competitiveness Nexus: Why Energy Determines Indonesia's Competitiveness
No country has ever become an industrial power merely because it had cheap labour. No country has won economic competition solely because it offered larger tax incentives.
Throughout history, every leap in industrialisation has rested on the same foundation: the ability to provide energy in sufficient quantities, at competitive prices, with reliable supply and long-term certainty.
During the Industrial Revolution, that advantage came from coal. In the 20th century, it shifted to oil and electricity. Now, as the world enters the era of artificial intelligence, data centres, electric vehicles and high-tech manufacturing, energy has once again become the factor that distinguishes countries capable of leading from those that merely serve as markets.
What has changed is not the importance of energy, but its role. Energy is no longer merely supporting infrastructure for development. Energy has become the primary source of a nation’s competitive advantage.
This change reflects the emergence of a new relationship between the energy system and economic competitiveness. In the modern economy, energy is no longer viewed solely as a production cost to be minimised, but as a strategic factor that determines investment decisions, industrial productivity, technological innovation, and a country’s position in the global value chain.
This relationship can be called the Energy-Competitiveness Nexus: the increasingly close link between the quality of a national energy system and a country’s ability to win economic competition.
This paradigm has emerged because the structure of the world economy is changing. For most of the 20th century, competitiveness was largely determined by manufacturing efficiency, labour costs, access to ports and the availability of raw materials. Those factors remain important, but they are no longer sufficient.
The industries that are now the engines of economic growth are precisely those that are highly dependent on energy. Data centres require uninterrupted electricity supply twenty-four hours a day. The semiconductor industry requires extremely stable power quality.
Nickel, aluminium and copper smelters consume energy on a very large scale. The production of batteries, electric vehicles, green hydrogen and artificial intelligence-based computing share the same characteristic: they are highly electricity-intensive. In this context, energy has shifted from being merely a supporting factor to a primary prerequisite for productivity.
This change is also visible in the strategies of the world’s largest technology companies. Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Meta and various data centre developers no longer invest only in chips, software or digital infrastructure.
They are also securing long-term power purchase agreements, investing in renewable energy generation, supporting the development of nuclear power and strengthening transmission networks. These steps show that in the digital economy, access to energy has become part of business strategy. Without certainty of electricity supply, investments worth billions of dollars will never be realised.
Consequently, competition between countries has also undergone a fundamental change. It is no longer enough for a country to offer industrial estates, modern ports or tax incentives. Investors now also assess whether a country’s energy system can guarantee industrial operations for the next two to three decades.
They pay attention to the reliability of the electricity grid, the stability of energy prices, transmission capacity, the existence of energy storage systems and the direction of long-term energy policy. Competitiveness is no longer determined solely by ease of doing business, but also by a country’s ability to provide the energy that underpins economic activity.
From this perspective, energy infrastructure development must be viewed as an economic investment, not merely an investment in the energy sector. Power plants do produce energy, but transmission networks enable that energy to create productivity. Energy storage systems maintain supply reliability.
Grid digitalisation improves efficiency and system resilience. All these components work together to create an environment conducive to investment and industrialisation. If toll roads lower logistics costs, then a reliable energy system lowers the cost of uncertainty for businesses.
Indonesia has a significant opportunity to capitalise on this paradigm shift. The mineral downstreaming agenda, electric vehicle development, industrial estate construction, economic digitalisation and higher economic growth targets will significantly increase electricity demand over the next two decades.
On the other hand, Indonesia has enormous renewable energy potential, still-abundant natural gas resources and strategic mineral reserves that form the foundation of the clean energy industry. This combination provides a strong initial capital base for building energy-based competitive advantage.
However, potential alone does not create competitiveness. What matters is the ability to transform that potential into a reliable, affordable and sustainable energy system. This requires consistent investment in power generation, transmission networks, inter-island interconnection, energy storage systems, grid digitalisation and governance capable of providing certainty for investors.
In an increasingly competitive economy, advantage no longer comes from who possesses the greatest resources, but from who is able to manage those resources into productivity.
Therefore, Indonesia needs to begin viewing energy policy as an inseparable part of industrial policy and investment policy. Energy planning is no longer sufficient if it merely calculates national electricity demand or the energy mix target.
That planning must also answer the needs of the sectors that will become Indonesia’s future economic growth engines. How much electricity capacity is needed to support mineral downstreaming?
How will the transmission network connect energy centres with industrial estates? How can the energy system support the growth of data centres and the digital economy? These questions must become part of the national development strategy.
This is the essence of the Energy-Competitiveness Nexus. Economic competitiveness is no longer built solely through capital, labour and transport infrastructure. Competitiveness is increasingly determined by a country’s ability to provide energy capable of driving industry, encouraging innovation and providing certainty for long-term investment. Countries that understand this relationship earlier will have a greater opportunity to become centres of manufacturing, technology and the digital economy in the future.
For many years, energy was viewed as a sector that followed economic growth. Now, that relationship has reversed. Energy increasingly determines where investment flows, where industry develops and where economic growth is created. In the 21st-century economy, competitive advantage is not built only in industrial estates, ports or toll roads. It is built through an energy system capable of serving as the foundation for all economic activity.
Because ultimately, competitiveness is no longer merely a matter of production costs. Competitiveness is a country’s ability to convert energy into productivity, innovation and prosperity. Energy no longer supports competitiveness. Energy has become competitiveness itself.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/energy-competitiveness-nexus-why-energy-determines-indonesias-competitiveness-1786240345)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260807072811-14-757285/energy-competitiveness-nexus-mengapa-energi-menentukan-daya-saing-ri), translated from Indonesian