Elite Schools Ditch Laptops in Unison – with Unexpected Results
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – A growing backlash against the use of gadgets in classrooms is taking hold in developed countries. A number of leading educational institutions in the United States and the United Kingdom are now taking the radical step of removing laptops and reviving traditional learning methods using pen and paper.
The screen-free approach is not without reason. In the US, the widespread use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) is making students less inclined to think critically, while in the UK, laptops in classrooms have been shown to distract students and erode their concentration.
UK: Elite school drops laptops as exam scores soar
In the UK, prestigious boarding school Winchester College, which charges £62,100 (about Rp1.5 billion) a year in fees, has officially ended the use of laptops in classrooms. The school’s first female head, Elizabeth Stone, said computers during lessons were more likely to distract students.
“There is no point restricting phones if we then give pupils laptops that they have to carry around all the time. Most of the distracting activities on phones can easily move over to tablets or laptops,” Stone told The Sunday Times, as quoted by the Telegraph on Thursday (12 November 2026).
The school had previously noticed a surge in internet traffic during the first lesson of the day, as students busied themselves checking emails. Winchester College has now reversed the rules.
Laptops are no longer the default classroom device, unless teachers can demonstrate a concrete educational benefit, such as 3D mathematical modelling, language flashcards or support for students with disabilities. New Year 9 pupils (equivalent to the third year of junior secondary school in Indonesia) are even allowed to bring only basic mobile phones.
The results were immediately apparent. In the 2026 GCSE national examinations, 95% of Winchester College pupils achieved the top grades (7 to 9), up from 93% the previous year. Pupils are also completing homework more quickly without distractions from YouTube or social media, leaving them more time to play sport and traditional games such as conkers.
The trend has prompted UK Shadow Education Secretary Laura Trott to urge the government to introduce similar rules in state schools, to prevent disparities in educational quality caused by exposure to screens.
US: AI onslaught sends universities back to exercise books and oral examinations
In the United States, the return to pen and paper has been prompted by concerns about AI misuse. A Pew Research Center survey found that 54% of US teenagers had used chatbots to do schoolwork, while 59% believed AI-assisted cheating was widespread at their schools.
As a result, essays and homework have lost their authority as teachers struggle to distinguish students’ own work from machine-generated output. The American Federation of Teachers has even called for a total ban on AI in primary schools, according to NCHstats on Thursday (12 November 2026).
In response to the threat, leading US universities are also overhauling their assessment systems:
Back to blue books: From the 2026–2027 academic year, the University of Chicago Law School will officially ban laptops, tablets and phones in compulsory first-year courses. Core examinations will be held entirely in class, using blue books and without internet access.
In-person oral examinations: Chris Schaffer, a biomedical engineering professor at Cornell University, is using 20-minute oral examinations to assess written assignments by his 70 students. The University of Pennsylvania also requires students to defend their paper arguments in person.
Conversation-based coding examinations: A 2026 study by researchers Lorena Barba and Laura Stegner tested a live programming examination format in which students may use supervised AI, provided they can explain the reasoning behind every line of code orally.
Not anti-technology, but protecting the foundations of thought
Although they are tightening classroom rules, educational institutions in the US and UK stress that the move does not amount to a wholesale rejection of technology. Completely shutting off access to AI could leave graduates unprepared for a modern workplace increasingly shaped by automation.
Many universities are therefore adopting a hybrid approach. Electronic devices are strictly limited in foundational courses to ensure students develop independent reasoning skills. Once that foundation is in place, students may use AI for advanced research under strict and transparent rules.
Ultimately, the standard for academic achievement is shifting well beyond simply submitting polished assignments. Students’ ability to reason independently, explain concepts and defend arguments before an examiner is once again becoming a key measure of academic success.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/elite-schools-ditch-laptops-in-unison-with-unexpected-results-1794498692)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20261112155805-37-784721/fenomena-sekolah-elit-kompak-buang-laptop-hasilnya-tak-terduga), translated from Indonesian