Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Elite Interests Behind the Tug-of-War Over the Asset Forfeiture Bill

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Elite Interests Behind the Tug-of-War Over the Asset Forfeiture Bill
Image: CNN Indonesia

Deliberation of the Asset Forfeiture Bill continues to drag on.

First proposed in 2008, some 17-18 years ago, three presidential terms have passed without significant progress on the bill’s deliberation. The reason is thought to be simple: the bill has become a ‘hot potato’ for the government and the House of Representatives (DPR) as lawmakers.

According to Herdiansyah Hamzah ‘Castro’, a researcher at the Anti-Corruption Study Centre (SAKSI) of the Faculty of Law at Mulawarman University (Unmul), the bill is stalled because DPR members themselves would be among those targeted.

“I have explained many times that this bill is not being discussed because, once it is gavelled through, those dragged in first would include DPR members who, according to the data, are the most frequently involved in corruption cases,” Castro said when contacted.

He outlined the many matters that must be regulated in the bill, such as the objects of forfeiture, illicit enrichment, and asset forfeiture processes that can be carried out without a criminal court verdict, or on a non-conviction basis.

“Equally important to regulate is how the forfeiture process can be carried out without a court ruling, or non-conviction based, an approach often used in practice in the United Kingdom, for instance,” Castro said.

“So, without a court ruling, those assets should be forfeitable by the state in the name of the public interest,” he added.

Castro also stressed that the deliberation process must involve as much public participation as possible, in line with Constitutional Court Decision Number 91/PUU-XVIII/2020.

In that ruling (p. 393), the Constitutional Court defined meaningful participation as: (1) the public’s right to have their views heard, (2) the public’s right to have their views considered, and (3) the public’s right to receive an explanation or response to the views submitted.

“What would a meaningful model look like? Those involved in the deliberation should include, for example, law enforcers, including anti-corruption activists who have long focused on the Asset Forfeiture Bill,” Castro said.

Zaenur Rohman, a researcher at the Anti-Corruption Study Centre at Gadjah Mada University (Pukat UGM), said deliberation of the Asset Forfeiture Bill is something the public has long been waiting for.

This is because the legal framework is considered capable of contributing positively to improving the effectiveness of corruption eradication and other types of criminal offences.

If the bill is passed into law, the hope is that perpetrators of crimes will find it difficult to enjoy the proceeds of their crimes.

“Because the proceeds of their crimes could easily be forfeited by the state,” Zaenur told CNNIndonesia.com on Wednesday (15/7).

He understands that debates have emerged along the way about how to balance the effectiveness of asset forfeiture with the protection of human rights.

In his view, that debate does not mean the state should be denied the opportunity to have effective regulation in combating extraordinary crimes.

Zaenur sees no progress in the process currently under way in the DPR.

Moreover, the public still finds it difficult to access the draft of the Asset Forfeiture Bill being deliberated.

“Our suggestion is for the DPR to have a draft that is open to the public, and then for every stage and every agenda item to be communicated to the public, along with the conclusions reached. Yes, the recordings are on YouTube, but that does not make it easier for the public to understand things in a more concise format,” he said.

He also reminded lawmakers not to rush the bill through simply to defuse overwhelming public pressure.

“This bill must not be done carelessly; it must demonstrate good quality. It must contribute to making asset forfeiture for crimes more effective,” Zaenur said.

Mitigating abuse of authority

One point raised by lawmakers regarding the bill is that they must be careful to avoid legislation that entrenches the abuse of authority. Zaenur agreed on the need for caution regarding articles at risk of becoming loopholes for the abuse of power or authority.

“Regarding the risk of abuse of authority in asset forfeiture, it is understood that no country can guarantee that asset forfeiture will be free from misuse. However, that does not mean there are no mechanisms that can reduce that opportunity,” he added.

Zaenur said there are various safeguards that could mitigate the abuse of authority by law enforcement officials in seizing assets.

First, all forms of coercive measures in the asset forfeiture mechanism must obtain substantive authorisation from a court.

Second, there must be a mechanism for aggrieved parties to file objections.

There must also be a mechanism for compensation where the state has wrongly carried out asset forfeiture.

“And in my view, the most important thing is that the asset forfeiture mechanism must not be monopolised by a single institution, let alone a single law enforcement agency,” he added.

Lakso Anindito, chair of the Indonesia Memanggil (IM57+) Institute, said that in terms of substance the bill shows no significant renewal.

Lakso said one of the core issues of asset forfeiture is the inclusion of illicit enrichment, or the illegal accumulation of unexplained wealth.

Based on the draft he obtained, the approach taken tends not to purely address unexplained wealth accumulation by state officials without needing to prove the alleged criminal offences involved.

In the existing draft concept, he explained, the approach still emphasises the position of state officials as suspects first.

“That creates the potential need for preliminary evidence of involvement in a crime beforehand. If that mechanism is used, the current Anti-Corruption Law already regulates this approach,” Lakso said.

“Yet, if we look more deeply at the UNCAC (United Nations Convention Against Corruption) concept, this provision should be applied by placing the burden of proof on state officials whose wealth has increased significantly, without first requiring suspect status in another case,” he continued.

Lakso also highlighted the execution of asset forfeiture, which leans towards the Attorney General’s Office alone. In his view, the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) has a strategic role in handling asset forfeiture.

“In other words, the aspirations of the Asset Forfeiture Bill must not go unfulfilled for lack of radical change,” he explained.

More from 16 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/elite-interests-behind-the-tug-of-war-over-the-asset-forfeiture-bill-1784195790)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260716111732-32-1381377/kepentingan-elite-di-balik-tarik-ulur-ruu-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian
Print