Eligible Professors and National Competitiveness Amidst the Nation
By Prof. Muhammad Turhan Yani; Professor and Head of the Institute for Research and Community Service (LPLP) at the State University of Surabaya.
At a time when the requirements to become a Professor (guru besar) are deemed increasingly difficult, as outlined in the Regulation of the Minister of Higher Education, Science, and Technology (Permendiktisaintek) 52 of 2025, some universities in Indonesia have released a list of ‘Eligible Professors’. These are lecturers declared worthy and meeting the criteria to propose advancement to the academic position (JAD) of Professor, but who have not yet met specific requirements that would otherwise disqualify them, even though their cumulative credit (KUM) scores exceed the necessary threshold.
The specific requirements mentioned in Article 42, point (g), involve a minimum of two scientific publications or two high-quality works of art. The specific requirements for scientific publications detailedly mandate metric indicators that measure the prestige, quality, and influence of a scientific journal, commonly known as the SCImago Journal Rank (SJR), as regulated in the technical guidelines of Kepmendiktisaintek No. 39/M/KEP/2026.
To propose becoming a Professor, a lecturer must have one scientific publication in a reputable international journal of at least Q2, with an SJR above 0.25 or an IF above 0.05 at the time of publication, and where the status is not cancelled or discontinued, serving as both the first and corresponding author. Additionally, they must have one scientific publication in a reputable international journal of at least Q3, with an SJR above 0.2 or an IF above 0.05, serving as either the first or corresponding author.
Rather than being easily fulfilled, these new regulations are viewed by some lecturers as becoming increasingly difficult, although others suggest they are merely more challenging compared to previous rules that required publications in Scopus-indexed international journals with an SJR > 0.10 or a WoS Impact Factor > 0.05 as the first author.
The surge in the number of ‘Eligible Professors’ released by some campuses, particularly State Universities (PTN), is startling, as their numbers are more than double the number of definitive professors. Overall in Indonesia, the number of existing definitive professors is currently around 3% of the total 330,000 lecturers. This figure remains very small, especially when compared to the number of professors in other countries.
In various developed nations, the proportion of lecturers holding professorships is much higher than in Indonesia. In the United States, approximately 10-15 percent of lecturers hold the title of professor, supported by a tenure-track system that provides a more structured career path. In the United Kingdom, around 12 percent of lecturers hold this position, which is considered a prestigious title.
The question remains: how can Indonesia accommodate these ‘Eligible Professors’ at a time when the Government is implementing efficiency policies? Will these efficiency policies impact the proposal process for becoming a ‘Definitive Professor’? Meanwhile, on the other hand, the latest requirements are deemed increasingly difficult compared to previous regulations. A solution to this issue must be found, especially for lecturers approaching the Age Limit for Retirement (BUP).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/eligible-professors-and-national-competitiveness-amidst-the-nation-1781686360)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tgroot483/profesor-eligible-dan-daya-saing-bangsa-di-tengah-bangsa), translated from Indonesian