Election Bill Hearing: UI Says ASN Lecturers Should Not Have to Resign Permanently When Running for Parliament
Universitas Indonesia (UI) has proposed that lecturers who are civil servants (ASN) and run for legislative office should not be required to resign permanently at the candidacy stage. Instead, UI says they should be placed on temporary inactive status while taking part in the nomination process.
The proposal was presented by UI Professor Valina Singka at a public hearing held by the House of Representatives Commission II to discuss input on the Election Bill, at the parliament building in Senayan, Jakarta, on Wednesday (11 November 2026). She said permanent resignation should be required only after an ASN lecturer has been confirmed as an elected legislative candidate.
“We believe—as the rector has emphasised—that ASN lecturers standing as legislative candidates should not have to resign permanently at the candidacy stage. Resignation should be required after they are confirmed as elected, and completed before their swearing-in,” Valina said.
During the nomination process, she said, the lecturers would be temporarily inactive. Those who were not elected could return to active service after relinquishing their membership and positions in political parties.
“During the candidacy process, they would be placed on temporary inactive status without state-funded benefits. If they are not elected, their reinstatement as ASN lecturers would be guaranteed after they leave their party membership and positions. Inactive status must take effect before they join a party or register as a candidate,” she said.
“They must also be prohibited from using their position, budget, facilities or academic authority for campaigning,” she added.
Valina said the arrangement would give academics the opportunity to contribute to representative institutions without losing their profession if they failed to win a legislative seat.
“Requiring permanent resignation from the moment of candidacy risks depriving our universities of talent, even when a lecturer does not win a seat. Temporary inactive status would open access for academics to representative institutions while preserving their contribution to higher education if they are not elected,” she said.
She added that academics’ presence in parliament could broaden the expertise available for lawmaking and oversight of the government. The House, she noted, has three constitutional functions: legislation, budgeting and oversight.
UI also proposed a dedicated chapter on the governance and ethical use of artificial intelligence (AI) in elections. Valina said campaign content produced using AI should be labelled.
“We propose requiring labels on campaign content created or manipulated using AI. There should be prohibitions and penalties for audio-visual fabrications, deepfakes, voice imitation and cloning, as well as deliberate disinformation intended to deceive voters or damage reputations through false representations,” she said.
Valina said voters were entitled to make their choices on the basis of authentic information. The manipulation of faces, voices and statements, she argued, undermined voters’ ability to assess candidates freely.
“Voters have the right to know genuinely and truthfully about the candidates standing in elections, whether for the legislature, the presidency or regional leadership,” she said.
UI also proposed setting the parliamentary threshold for allocating seats in the House of Representatives at no more than 4%. The university said a maximum threshold of 4% was needed to preserve the proportionality of election results.
“Universitas Indonesia proposes that the vote threshold for allocating seats in the House of Representatives be no higher than 4%, with the level based on accountable calculations that preserve proportionality and reduce the number of valid votes that are not converted into seats,” Valina said.
She cited the 2019 election, when the parliamentary threshold meant that about 13.5 million votes, or 9.7% of valid votes nationwide, did not translate into seats in the House. The figure rose in the 2024 election.
“In 2024, it increased to 11.4%. That was about 17.3 million votes that were also wasted and could not be converted because the parties failed to pass the 4% threshold,” she said.
Valina stressed that the proposed maximum 4% threshold would apply only to elections for the national House. UI proposed no parliamentary threshold for provincial or district and municipal regional councils.
“In our view, the 4% threshold should apply only at the national House level, and not to regional councils, whether provincial or district and municipal,” she said.
“This is about protecting the people’s votes. We believe that simplifying the party system does not have to rely continually on restricting the threshold for the House, which has increased from one election to the next,” she added.
Valina also proposed abolishing the presidential nomination threshold. She said the 1945 Constitution sets no threshold for nominating presidential and vice-presidential candidates.
“Universitas Indonesia’s proposal is for no presidential threshold, or 0%. This is also consistent with Constitutional Court Decision No. 62 of 2024,” she concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/election-bill-hearing-ui-says-asn-lecturers-should-not-have-to-resign-permanently-when-running-for-parliament-1794401509)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8748783/rapat-ruu-pemilu-ui-usul-dosen-asn-tak-perlu-mundur-permanen-saat-nyaleg), translated from Indonesian