Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Editorial

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Editorial

Caning the USA?

Washington seems determined to put Singapore on the human
rights map by raising the issue of caning a convict, who just
happens to be an American teenager named Michael Fay, who lives
in the Southeast Asian republic.

The court sentence for the offense committed -- vandalism --
meted out Singapore-style, has been common on the island for
decades. The courts there have periodically handed out such
sentences to other teenagers convicted for various offenses. But
no sooner than the 18-year-old American resident of Singapore was
sentenced by a local court for vandalism early last month, did
President Bill Clinton jump into the fray in Fay's defense.

Clinton asked his secretary of state to lodge a strong protest
with the Singapore government and urged the Singaporean
authorities to reconsider the sentence. Fay, who pleaded guilty
of spray painting two cars, is now in prison awaiting the caning
after Singapore's chief justice turned down his appeal against
the lower court's verdict.

Caning a vandal is alien to the U.S. legal system. In this
context, Clinton's concern over the court-ordered caning is
understandable. It is also an American tradition to take care of
the nations citizens in every corner of the globe.

However, President Clinton's strong protest does not sound so
reasonable in this part of the hemisphere and is completely
unacceptable to Singapore.

The Straits Times, the island's largest newspaper, had
received 120 letters from its readers on the matter by last week,
90 percent of which supported the sentence, while the rest
remained neutral.

The American reality of societal chaos reflected in
media reports of murder, rape, drug abuse and other criminal
offenses, seemingly caused Lee Kuan Yew, Singapore's founding
father, to react strongly against the American stance on caning
in a television interview on Tuesday. He seemed to be hinting
that a country like the U.S. has no right to advise what a law-
abiding nation like Singapore must do to keep its residents
disciplined. He must have observed that the absence of caning in
the U.S. legal system did nothing to guarantee that the country
would be free of crime.

The feeling of unpleasantness raised among Singaporeans by
President Clinton's protest might have been spurred by the fact
that Washington never raised the issue in the past although many
people have been sentenced to caning in Singapore for various
offenses. To Singapore's leaders, as to the leaders of many
developing countries, this latest move by the U.S. must seem
little more than an extension of the usual double standard
adopted by American policy makers.

No nation -- however small or poor it might be and certainly
not a rich one like Singapore -- can be expected to be willing to
be dictated to on the question of its legal system by another
country, particularly one in which the public's safety is a
matter of uncertainty.

The problem is that the United States never seems to hesitate
to impose its moral values on others, particularly when the
others are developing, or Asian nations. It is high time that
Washington realized that this kind of attitude is no longer
relevant and certainly not beneficial given the changing pattern
of international relations.

More from 14 April 1994 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/editorial-1447899208-1021619)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print