Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Economist urges separation of IDX regulatory function in demutualisation

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Economist urges separation of IDX regulatory function in demutualisation
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) - PermataBank Chief Economist Josua Pardede has urged the separation of the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) regulatory function in the demutualisation process by establishing a dedicated regulatory body within the IDX group.

As is known, the Financial Services Authority (OJK) is currently drafting a Demutualisation POJK, one provision of which regulates the separation of the IDX’s regulatory function from its business development function.

“In my view, the separation should not stop at dividing divisions within the same building. A stronger option is to establish a separate regulatory body within the IDX group,” Josua said in a written response to ANTARA in Jakarta on Friday.

The regulatory body, Josua explained, needs to have a supervisory board with an independent majority, a guaranteed budget, and a head who reports to the supervisory board and the OJK, not to the IDX president director who has revenue targets.

The body would later handle listing assessments, compliance of listed companies, supervision of Exchange Members, transaction examinations, and sanction recommendations.

The IDX’s commercial management, he continued, must not be able to alter examination results out of consideration for potentially losing listed companies, Exchange Members, transactions, or revenue.

Beyond the separation of functions, Josua believes there needs to be a mechanism for the OJK to take over decision-making when the IDX has a direct interest in a matter.

For example, if a matter concerns IDX shareholders, IDX subsidiaries, companies controlled by Danantara, or the IDX itself, regulatory decisions should not be made by the IDX but should automatically be escalated to the OJK or an independent committee with no relationship to the parties involved.

He considers Singapore to be one possible reference for such a separation of functions. The Singapore Exchange (SGX) has the objective of running a business for profit while also bearing market regulatory obligations.

To reduce conflicts of interest, Singapore established SGX Regulation as a dedicated subsidiary that carries out all front-line regulatory functions.

“The majority of its board, including the chairman, is independent of the SGX group, and the entire board must be independent of listed companies and SGX members. This body reports on the implementation of its regulatory duties to the Monetary Authority of Singapore and to the SGX board,” Josua explained.

A similar model is also applied in Malaysia through a regulatory subsidiary of Bursa Malaysia that has taken over the exchange’s regulatory functions. Its board has an independent majority from Bursa Malaysia, while the Securities Commission Malaysia continues to oversee the exchange and ensure the regulatory body has adequate human and financial resources.

Bursa Malaysia also uses a regulatory committee to make key decisions concerning listings, market participants, and appeals. The committee is mostly filled by outside experts, together with independent directors and public interest representatives.

According to Josua, Malaysia can serve as a reference that is relatively easy to adapt to Indonesia because both countries are in the Southeast Asian capital market system and both maintain a state regulator above an exchange that has a self-regulatory function.

Meanwhile, the Japan Exchange Group places its self-regulatory function in Japan Exchange Regulation as a separate legal entity within the same group. The body conducts examinations independently and neutrally, while its highest decision-making body has a majority of members from outside the exchange group.

Josua assesses that the experience of these three countries shows that separating functions does not require severing all ties between the regulatory body and the exchange.

The regulatory body still needs to be close to the trading system in order to understand market conditions quickly, but its examination process and conclusions must be free from commercial interests.

As for Hong Kong, he considers it relevant to addressing concerns about government involvement in the exchange structure. The Hong Kong government can appoint board members of Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX), but the number appointed by the government may not exceed the number of members elected by shareholders.

Furthermore, he notes that HKEX holds the principle that when the company’s interests conflict with the public interest, the public interest must take precedence.

When HKEX has a conflict of interest as a listed company, Hong Kong’s market regulator takes over the functions normally performed by the exchange. The listing function is also separated from revenue-generating activities and overseen by a committee independent of the company’s board.

“So, Hong Kong’s experience shows that state involvement does not automatically eliminate independence, as long as state representation is limited, the majority of organs are truly independent, and the external regulator has the authority to take over when conflicts arise,” Josua explained.

Overall, for Indonesia, Josua sees that the applicable model is not to copy one country but to combine several elements from these various models.

The elements include dispersed ownership without a single controller; the Ministry of Finance, Bank Indonesia, and Danantara as minority shareholders if necessary; an independent majority on the Board of Commissioners; separation of regulatory functions as in Singapore, Malaysia, and Japan; and OJK authority to take over matters when the IDX or its shareholders have a direct interest.

More from 7 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-urges-separation-of-idx-regulatory-function-in-demutualisation-1786118059)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5685057/ekonom-dorong-pemisahan-fungsi-pengaturan-bei-dalam-demutualisasi), translated from Indonesian
Print