Economist: Sharia Finance Must Not Be a Mere Appendage in PFII Law
The Head of the Center for Sharia Economic Development at the Institute for Development of Economics and Finance (Indef), Nur Hidayah, has stated that sharia finance is insufficiently addressed by merely being listed as a business sector in the design of the Indonesian International Financial Centre (PFII). She argued that the sharia aspect must be institutionalised through a clear institutional and governance framework to give the PFII a distinct advantage over other global financial centres.
Nur explained that there are three levels of debate in the PFII design: macro, meso, and micro. At the macro level, the debate concerns the legitimacy of the PFII in attracting global fund potential and the accompanying risks. At the meso level, questions arise regarding the PFII’s competitive edge if all its provisions merely adopt international standards. At the micro level, the issue is the positioning of sharia finance within the PFII.
‘From a macro perspective, is the PFII necessary? There is a contestation of legitimacy between the potential of global funds and the risks of money laundering, tax base erosion, and barriers to OECD accession. At the meso level, the question is what differentiates it if all rules copy international standards; where is the PFII’s speciality? Relying solely on fiscal incentives has proven fragile. Then at the micro level, if it is a sharia PFII, where is the sharia aspect? Sharia is mentioned as a business sector, but it has not been institutionalised as a principle of governance and institutional framework,’ Nur said during a public discussion titled ‘Sharia PFII: Is Indonesia Ready to Become an International Sharia Financial Centre?’ held online on Friday.
Nur was particularly critical of the PFII’s value proposition if it relies solely on fiscal incentives. She argued that differentiation must come from product and ecosystem specialisation, not from regulatory leniency. She further assessed that a zero per cent tax incentive cannot be a sustainable advantage. Moreover, the global trend towards a minimum tax for large multinational corporations could prevent investors from fully enjoying such benefits, while the state still faces the risk of losing tax revenue. Additionally, providing fiscal facilities could create a spillover effect, as business actors outside the zone might demand similar facilities. Such incentives are also more easily accessed by high-income and highly educated groups, risking an uneven distribution of benefits that excludes micro, small, and medium enterprises (UMKM).
‘So, if fiscal investment is structurally fragile, the attractiveness of the PFII must be built on legal certainty, institutional quality, and product specialisation. These three things can actually be provided by a mature sharia architecture,’ she said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-sharia-finance-must-not-be-a-mere-appendage-in-pfii-law-1786107106)
Originally published by Republika (https://sharia.republika.co.id/berita/tjeema423/ekonom-indef-keuangan-syariah-jangan-sekadar-jadi-tempelan-di-uu-pfii), translated from Indonesian