Economist says cigarette pricing policy must consider market structure
Any policy that creates greater space for low-priced products needs to consider its impact on market structure, according to Yusuf Rendy Manilet, an economist from the Centre of Reform on Economics (Core).
Speaking in Jakarta on Tuesday, Manilet noted that the phenomenon of ‘downtrading’ has been occurring in recent years and represents a significant challenge in the implementation of tobacco excise policies. According to Yusuf, increases in excise tariffs, followed by price disparities between product groups, have encouraged some consumers to switch to cheaper cigarettes.
“Therefore, any policy that opens up more space for low-priced products needs to consider its impact on the market structure,” he said. He assessed that if more cheap cigarette options become available, the tendency for consumers to migrate to lower-priced products is likely to continue.
This condition, he added, must be a consideration in the formulation of excise policy to ensure that the goals of controlling consumption and optimising state revenue can be balanced effectively.
A similar view was expressed by Universitas Airlangga economist Rumayya Batubara. She stated that policies regarding the tobacco industry must consider various simultaneous challenges, ranging from regulatory uncertainty and excise increase pressures to the downtrading phenomenon and the circulation of illegal cigarettes.
She warned that if pressure on the industry continues to increase without adequate mitigation, the impact will not only be felt by industry players but could also affect economic activities in tobacco-producing regions through the weakening of supply chains, community consumption, and employment opportunities.
The downtrading phenomenon itself remains a key issue in tobacco excise policy discussions. The widening price gap between product segments in recent years is seen as a specific challenge in maintaining the balance between state revenue, the effectiveness of consumption control, industry sustainability, and labour protection.
These discussions emerged after Andi Yuliani Paris, a member of Commission XI of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) from the PAN faction, proposed during a hearing with several Directors General at the Ministry of Finance that the government should allow production space for cigarettes targeting lower-income segments. She argued that high cigarette prices are driving some members of the public toward cheaper, illegal cigarettes.
Meanwhile, the Director General of Customs and Excise, Djaka Budi Utama, explained that the government currently faces two main challenges in managing tobacco excise: the increasing practice of downtrading, where consumers shift to lower-priced products, and the circulation of illegal cigarettes. He noted that both factors affect efforts to optimise state revenue.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-says-cigarette-pricing-policy-must-consider-market-structure-1782791607)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5628315/ekonom-nilai-kebijakan-harga-rokok-perlu-pertimbangkan-struktur-pasar), translated from Indonesian