Economist: Recovery in Public Sentiment Remains Very Fragile
Economist Yusuf Rendy Manilet from the Centre of Reform on Economics (CORE) stated that the recovery in public sentiment is beginning to emerge but remains very thin. He reminded that the Consumer Confidence Index (CCI) stood at 127 in January and continued to decline to 116.8 in July.
Therefore, according to Yusuf, the increase to 118.5 in August only recovers a small portion of that decline. “This is more accurately described as a rebound from a low point, rather than a reversal of the trend,” he said when contacted on Thursday (10/9).
Looking at its components, he continued, the current economic condition is also not yet very strong. The Current Economic Condition Index (IKE) stands at 109.4, while the Consumer Expectation Index (IEK) reached 127.6.
“This means that the public is still far more optimistic about the future compared to the conditions they are experiencing now,” Yusuf explained.
On the other hand, he noted that the Job Availability Index (IKLK) did rise from 101.1 to 104.1, but its position remains only slightly above the optimistic threshold. “The foundations of the recovery are not yet solid,” he remarked.
Regarding consumption, Yusuf stated that the increase in the proportion of income allocated to spending from 72.7% to 74.2% also needs to be read with caution. This figure could reflect improving consumer confidence, but it could also indicate that households are beginning to reduce savings to maintain consumption amidst rising prices.
“Moreover, inflation in August rose to 3.19%, primarily driven by food price pressures,” he added.
Real economic data is also deemed to be providing inconsistent signals. The manufacturing PMI for August fell below 50 again, while retail sales growth is expected to slow. Although second-quarter economic growth reached 5.29%, household consumption grew by 5.06 per cent and government consumption surged by 15.97 per cent.
“This means that the drivers of growth have not yet fully originated from private demand,” said Yusuf.
Furthermore, Yusuf continued, the rise in the Jakarta Composite Index (IHSG) cannot be immediately regarded as evidence of improvement in the real sector. This is because the stock market is highly responsive to liquidity and expectations.
“Liquidity injections into the banking sector may first drive asset prices, but the process of translating this into credit, consumption, and investment takes time. Therefore, capital market movements need to be separated from indicators of public purchasing power,” he explained.
Previously, Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa assessed that public sentiment began to show signs of recovery in August 2026 after being on a downward trajectory in the preceding months. According to Purbaya, the improvement in sentiment began to manifest alongside the impact of several government stimuli provided from late July to early August 2026. The improving sentiment is reflected in the Consumer Confidence Index (CCI) released by Bank Indonesia (BI), which increased to the 118.5 level in August, from 116.8 in July 2026.
“There is a reversal in public sentiment. Most likely, the improvement seen in the capital and financial markets reflects real improvements in our economy,” the Finance Minister said in Jakarta yesterday.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-recovery-in-public-sentiment-remains-very-fragile-1789034133)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/931901/ekonom-pemulihan-sentimen-masyarakat-masih-sangat-tipis), translated from Indonesian