Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Economist: PFII Needs Strong Foundation Before Tax Incentives

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Economist: PFII Needs Strong Foundation Before Tax Incentives
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) — Yusuf Rendy Manilet, an economist at the Center of Reform on Economics (CORE), believes the Indonesian International Financial Centre (PFII) requires a strong foundation before offering tax incentives, so that it can attract investors through legal certainty and a credible regulator.

He added that, based on the experience of various financial centres, investors also consider ease of capital repatriation, deep financial markets and certainty in dispute resolution.

“Tax only becomes an added value when that foundation is already strong. If the foundation is not ready, incentives that are too generous actually signal that we are trying to cover structural weaknesses with a tax discount,” Yusuf told ANTARA by telephone in Jakarta on Friday.

Yusuf also assessed that the effectiveness of tax incentives in attracting investors is limited, particularly as Indonesia has already implemented the 15 per cent global minimum tax in line with OECD Pillar Two.

“For large multinational companies, if Indonesia does not collect the tax, the shortfall can still be collected by the investor’s home country. As a result, Indonesia loses potential revenue without genuinely improving its investment appeal. The greatest benefits would potentially accrue to entities outside the scope of these rules, such as family offices or medium-sized investment funds,” he explained.

He added that the same applies to oversight. According to Yusuf, the challenge is not to add many supervisory bodies, but to ensure the design of the rules from the outset does not create loopholes for abuse.

Facilities, he argued, should also be limited only to entities that genuinely have real economic activity in the zone, rather than companies that merely relocate their registered address.

“Equally important, tax facilities must not become a gateway for shifting income that actually originates from Indonesia. If that happens, PFII would not create new investment, but merely move the tax base from one region to another,” Yusuf said.

He warned of a considerably high round-tripping risk, noting that some Indonesian capital has long returned via other jurisdictions and been recorded as foreign investment.

“If the design of PFII is not careful, this zone could instead become a cheaper route for such practices,” he said.

Therefore, Yusuf continued, supervision must not merely look at investors’ countries of origin, but must be able to identify the ultimate beneficial owners and ensure incoming funds are genuinely new capital.

From a governance perspective, he also views the regulator’s credibility as far more important than the size of fiscal incentives. In this regard, the regulator must be independent of both the zone’s managers and business players to avoid conflicts of interest.

Investors also need certainty that contracts can be enforced, disputes are resolved quickly, rules do not change easily, and capital can flow in and out without obstacles.

“Without all of that, no matter how large the tax incentives, they will not be enough to build trust,” Yusuf said.

For context, the government and the House of Representatives (DPR RI) are currently drafting the PFII bill, which is expected to be approved by all factions at the Second-Level Deliberation or Plenary Session on 21 July 2026.

The bill is also targeted for enactment into law within three months, between June and August 2026.

Mukhamad Misbakhun, Chair of Commission XI of the DPR RI, revealed that the government has proposed a 0 per cent tax incentive for businesses in the PFII zone, applicable for up to 50 years.

“A tax of 0 per cent — the government will provide that for up to 50 years. In my personal view, the incentive should be attached for as long as PFII exists. But the government wants 50 years. Still, 50 years is fine, because we want to see what developments over the next 50 years will look like,” Misbakhun said at the Investment Forum 2026 at the Indonesia Stock Exchange in Jakarta on Wednesday (15/7).

More from 17 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-pfii-needs-strong-foundation-before-tax-incentives-1784292923)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5654336/ekonom-pfii-perlu-fondasi-kuat-sebelum-pemberian-insentif-pajak), translated from Indonesian
Print