Economist: Multi-layered supervision needed to ensure objective price discovery for BMKS
Professor Rahma Gafmi from the Faculty of Economics and Business at Universitas Airlangga (Unair) believes that a multi-layered regulatory and supervisory architecture is essential to ensure that price discovery on the strategic minerals and commodities exchange (BMKS) remains objective, reflects supply and demand, and is immune to manipulation by major players.
In this regard, she stated that regulators and the exchange must establish maximum limits on the number of contracts or physical volumes that a single entity or related business group can control simultaneously. This would prevent one or two large players from dominating the supply or demand sides to dictate market prices, Rahma noted during an interview in Jakarta on Tuesday.
She added that every market participant must undergo a strict identity verification process. Furthermore, there must be a clear separation between the funds or positions of brokers and their clients, alongside real-time reporting of open positions to supervisory authorities to detect anomalies or market power concentration early.
The exchange must also implement automatic trading halts in the event of unusual price surges or drops that fall outside normal deviation limits. This step, accordingity to Rahma, would provide regulators with time to investigate whether such movements are driven by economic fundamentals or indicate manipulation, such as wash trading and spoofing.
Rahma explained that the integrity of price discovery depends heavily on the diversity of market participants. She believes the exchange ecosystem must ensure balanced participation from various parties, including independent producers, State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), large corporations, downstream consumers, institutional investors, and healthy speculators providing liquidity. “The more independent parties involved in transactions, the harder it will be for dominant players to engineer prices,” she said.
Additionally, the exchange and supervisory authorities need to implement AI-driven surveillance systems capable of automatically scanning for suspicious transaction patterns. Such systems could detect cross-trades between affiliates intended to deceive the market, as well as price manipulation during the closing seconds of a session, known as ‘marking the close’.
Rahma stated that heavy administrative and even criminal sanctions must be applied transparently and without prejudice against fraudulent trading practices, manipulation, or the abuse of dominant positions. Consistent law enforcement is necessary to provide a deterrent effect and maintain market confidence.
She noted that Indonesia has the opportunity to transition from a price-taker to a price-maker for certain commodities, given the country’s large global market share, particularly in nickel and tin, with potential in copper and other critical mineral downstream products. However, this requires all physical export volumes to be pulled and consolidated through a transparent domestic exchange, so that domestic price formation can serve as a benchmark for offshore buyers.
According to her, this target is realistic in the long term, but remains ambitious and challenging in the short to medium term. She added that realisation will not happen automatically simply because Indonesia possesses large commodity reserves; rather, it depends on the consistency of downstreaming policies and export regulations that mandate transactions through the exchange.
“As long as the government consistently mandates that all strategic commodity export transactions must pass through the BMKS—similar to the DMO or export proceeds foreign exchange obligation schemes—foreign buyers will be compelled to enter the domestic exchange ecosystem, which will instantly boost liquidity and establish a benchmark,” said Rahma.
However, she warned that the global market will not immediately abandon established exchanges such as the London Metal Exchange (LME) or the Shanghai Futures Exchange (SHFE). Global industry players are accustomed to using deep and flexible hedging instruments available on those exchanges.
“If the BMKS does not provide equivalent and liquid derivative financial instruments, global buyers will continue to use LME prices plus a certain premium or discount, leaving Indonesia trapped as a price-taker,” Rahma explained.
She also noted that global investors are highly sensitive to the risk of sudden regulatory changes, such as export bans or changes in royalties. If the governance of the BMKS is not fully independent and transparent, Rahma warned that the international market may perceive the prices formed there as not purely reflecting market forces, but rather being influenced by bureaucratic intervention. Such a condition could hinder the BMKS from becoming a global price benchmark.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-multi-layered-supervision-needed-to-ensure-objective-price-discovery-for-bmks-1788873124)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5731821/ekonom-perlu-pengawasan-berlapis-agar-price-discovery-bmks-objektif), translated from Indonesian