Economist Highlights Risks of PT DSI as 'Super Trader' for National Commodities
Jakarta - The government’s plan to establish PT Danantara Sumberdaya Indonesia (DSI) as a strategic commodity export entity has drawn criticism.
Senior economist at Paramadina University, Wijayanto Samirin, warned the concept poses excessive risks if DSI is tasked with becoming a “super trader” for national commodity exports.
According to Wijayanto, commodity trading business models are far more complex than simply purchasing goods from domestic producers and reselling them overseas.
“If DSI’s concept follows the president’s speech—buying products from domestic producers and handling exports—I believe it would fail,” Wijayanto told Kompas.com on Friday (29 May 2026).
He noted thousands of overseas buyers with varying contracts, quality standards, and payment terms.
“Imagine hundreds of producers and thousands of buyers with differing product varieties and contract terms. It’s extremely complex,” he said.
Beyond transactions, commodity trading involves insurance, international shipping, and substantial working capital requirements.
Wijayanto estimated DSI’s annual working capital needs could reach Rp250 trillion to Rp330 trillion when managing exports of three key commodities.
“Coal, CPO, and iron alloy exports total around Rp1,100 trillion annually. Commodity traders typically require working capital of 25% to 30% of annual sales,” he explained.
He also highlighted international businesses’ lack of confidence in Indonesia’s legal system, noting many global importers prefer purchasing through Singapore-based firms due to greater legal certainty.
“Many importers buy through Singapore-based companies because of better legal certainty,” he said.
Therefore, he argued that establishing DSI could create new intermediary chains if not carefully designed.
He proposed oversight functions through collaboration between PT Surveyor Indonesia, PT Sucofindo, and international bodies like SGS Switzerland.
This model, he said, is more realistic as it avoids massive working capital needs and disrupts existing business mechanisms.
“This approach is simpler, does not harm the business climate, and has a higher chance of success,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economist-highlights-risks-of-pt-dsi-as-super-trader-for-national-commodities-1780038185)
Originally published by Kompas (https://money.kompas.com/read/2026/05/29/130446226/ekonom-soroti-risiko-pt-dsi-jadi-super-trader-komoditas-negara?utm_source=ABC&utm_medium=rss), translated from Indonesian